subscribe: Posts | Comments

‘Fetus murder’ debate sparked by suicide attempt

0 comments

Summary of story from Care2, December 14, 2011

The Indiana Court of Appeals today heard testimony on the case of Bei Bei Shuai, who ingested rat poison in a suicide attempt which caused her to go into preterm labor at 33 weeks and her baby to die shortly afterwards (see WVoN story).

The state doesn’t see the attempt as suicide, but as an act of murder of a viable fetus.

The case has sparked a debate over whether the rights of a fetus actually outweigh the rights of the woman carrying it.

Numerous groups have asked for Ms Shuai to be released from prison, where she has been held without bail since March, saying you cannot be prosecuted for suicide attempts.

But the state’s Attorney General refused, saying: “This case generates strong opinions, but the state’s position adheres to the longstanding principle that a jury must weigh any facts, even those that go to the defendant’s intent, and therefore the trial court is where this case belongs.”

According to the Greenfield Reporter,  Ms Shuai’s attorney, Linda Pence, argues that Indiana’s law was written to protect fetuses from violence from third parties, not from their own mothers.

She says suicide isn’t a crime and Shuai could not have expected to be arrested.

WVON comment: Clearly the mother has severe mental issues if she is suicidal.

Incarcerating and treating her as someone in a sane state of mind is failing to honour any human rights at all, which is what the case is regarding.

It seems the prosecution cares more about making an example of her rather than concern itself with her welfare.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *