subscribe: Posts | Comments

Gender violence on New York public transport

4 comments

Polly Trenow
WVoN co-editor 

“This guy was standing between the edge of the platform and the staircase… He walked towards me while I was walking towards the platform. Unexpectedly he came in front of me and groped me on my chest!”

“I was walking home from the C train at Lafayette … I saw a man leaning against a parked silver car… As I came around the parked car… I noticed that he was masturbating right in front of me…”

“I was waiting on the uptown platform for the A train at around midnight on a weekday…. I look up to see a man standing on the stairs that lead to the suspended walkway, masturbating. I froze and then started yelling something, I don’t remember what, some profanities and ‘I’m going to call the cops’.”

These are three stories from New Yorkers that occurred last month. There are plenty more posted on the Hollaback! NYC website.

Unfortunately these stories are just the tip of the iceberg since, according to a 2007 study, 63 percent of New Yorkers have experienced harassment on NYC public transport.

Barely any of these incidents are reported to Metro Transit Authority staff or the police.

Women don’t report these incidents because they fear not being taken seriously, being blamed for their assault or they don’t think anything will be done about it.

This is what the Talking Back: Facing Gender Violence on NYC Transit conference at NYC’s Hunter College was convened to discuss on November 5, 2011.

On the panel were Emily May, co-founder and executive director, Hollaback!; Jerin Afria, chair of the National Organization for Women Young Feminist Task Force; Hilary Nemchik, chair, Domestic Violence Task Force at the Office of the Manhattan Borough President; and Susan Moesker, coordinator, Community Violence. Professor Gail Garfield, of John Jay College, moderated the discussion.

Street harassment ranges from leery looks, cat-calling and hissing, public masturbation, groping and other sexual assault and violence to rape and murder.

Though the majority – 98 percent – of victims are women and perpetrators men, men with gay, transgender and queer identities report harassment as well.

Emily May co-founded Hollaback! when it became apparent that street harassment stories were common among her peers but most of them thought it only happened to them.

The website provides local forums where women and men can post their experiences of harassment.

It encourages reporting and empowers local chapters to push for change in their areas.

Hollaback! now has groups in 45 cities in 16 different countries, operating in nine different languages.

Together the stories make for a depressing picture: everywhere the same problem.

Though progress is slow, things are beginning to change.

After a string of sexual assaults in the Park Slope area of NYC, a great community response encouraged women to report their attacks, motivating the police to step up their presence and eventually arresting two suspects.

However, more needs to be done to encourage victims to report incidents.

In 2007 Hollaback! along with the Metro Transit authority produced educational posters and announcements instructing travellers on how to report harassment.

But there is still a lack of research in this area, and the NYPD have yet to release figures to allow tracking of sexual assault and harassment.

Legislating against verbal harassment is also complicated.

Hollaback! do not support such a move because of the potential difficulties in enforcement, and they are concerned that it would be used to target individuals from lower socio-economic groups.

But they do advocate awareness-raising.

We can all do our bit by discussing street harassment with our friends and encouraging others to report incidents to the authorities or to a Hollaback! site.

Educate yourself about how to respond to harassers or intervene if you witness an incident.

If there is not yet a Hollaback! group in your area then think about starting one.

May says her hope is that one day street harassment will become like harassment in the work place.

We all know it’s unacceptable and we know something can be done about it.

  1. vicki wharton says:

    And we need to challenge male cultural opinion formers such as the men’s media that positions gender violence as ‘funny’ by Hollaing back via the media, the internet and anywhere else that gender violence is endorsed as a ‘laugh’.

    • For some reason I was thinking of a sociology experiment, for University undergraduates, in which young men agree to be treated as their female classmates feel they are treated by straight men, for a period of a week or two. I imagine that quite a few would cheerfully volunteer and expect that it wouldn’t be so bad to be complimented on their appearance etc. as they might imagine women are. I wonder how many would catch the hint that even such ‘low-level’ harassments as whistling and the like are intimidating and not complimentary at all. As for those who masturbate in public, they should not have the privilege of sharing public space if they can’t police their own actions. Whether they need treatment or punishment is not so clear.

      Perhaps we should embark on commenting with just a holla if we see these things endorsed online? Goodness knows that rational argument soon descends into bickering and entrenched views, so why not just give a holla and let those who don’t already know figure it out for themselves?

      • vicki wharton says:

        I try and use the public media spaces on the internet as places to safely challenge this type of behaviour. Yes, I may not change the viewpoint of the people I am going up against in debate, but at least it leaves a public record of a different viewpoint for other people to read and perhaps think about?

        • I don’t disagree. 🙂 I’ve yet to see someone change their views online, but I accept that it is unlikely to be as a result of an epiphany so I probably wouldn’t be privy to the change of heart.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *