Frequent bone scans may not be needed for many women
Summary of story from ABC News, January 19, 2012
A new study has shown that many older women do not need to be screened for bone density as often as recommended.
Government advisers and leading doctor groups urge osteoporosis screening, but no one has known how often that should happen.
If an initial bone scan shows no big problems, many can safely wait 15 years to have another one, the study suggests.
The new study feeds concerns that the tests are done too often, at least for some women.
“It’s an expenditure of time, it’s exposure to radiation, and it’s cost. And there’s no reason to expose yourself to any risks if there’s going to be no benefit,” explained Dr Virginia Moyer, who heads the US Preventive Services Task Force, a government panel that issues testing guidelines.
The government task force recommends that all women over 65 get a scan. The panel also recommends testing for younger postmenopausal women who seem at higher risk for fractures.
But the task force has not said how often follow-up tests should be done, just that a couple of years between tests are needed.
The research, published in Thursday’s New England Journal of Medicine, was led by Dr Margaret Gourlay of the University of North Carolina.
She worries that her findings might be misinterpreted and cause some women to wait longer than they should for their next test. She cited earlier research suggesting not enough women get the recommended initial scan.
She also noted that osteoporosis becomes a greater risk in the oldest patients, so a woman with a moderate risk who is 85 or older might be better off getting tested every three years instead of every five.











