Specialist domestic violence services – a thing of the past?
Heather Kennedy
WVoN co-editor
Government cuts are leaving many vulnerable women with no escape from domestic violence as refuges close and women are turned away, a report revealed last week (see WVoN story).
And for specialist voluntary and community organisations (VCOs) who help isolated Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) women fleeing domestic violence, the outlook is particularly grim.
Mainstream services have historically failed to reach BME women whose experiences of domestic violence can be distinct, often shaped by factors such as forced marriage, language barriers and racism.
British South Asian women experiencing domestic violence are significantly more likely to self harm and commit suicide than white British women.
Specialist domestic violence services sprang up to meet the needs of BME communities and use expert knowledge to reach and support BME women facing abuse.
For a long time however, specialist domestic violence services have had to defend their right to provide tailored services to BME women.
In 2008, Southall Black Sisters, who have been running refuges for BME women fleeing violence since 1979, won a legal battle against Ealing Council which tried to withdraw their funding, saying they should be providing a more ‘inclusive’ service.
But the council was forced to overturn this decision when Lord Justice Moses ruled that:
“Specialist services for a racial minority from a specialist source is anti-discriminatory and furthers the objectives of equality and cohesion.”
Women working across the women’s sector agree that specialist services are needed in tackling domestic violence. Cat Whitehouse from the domestic violence charity, Eaves, says:
“Whilst domestic violence services are often culturally sensitive, most do not have the resources to specifically target women in different communities and earn the trust necessary for women to feel able to access their services.
“Cost alone prevents many services from being truly inclusive, for example having translators or multi-lingual staff readily available and having enough money to translate forms and leaflets into community languages and then the information given translated back into English.”
But now, domestic violence services for BME women may become a thing of the past. Southall Black Sisters are facing severe funding cuts and Imkaan, who represent BME VCOs, have had to close two of its six refuges.
Vandna Gohil, Director of Voice4Change England, a BME advocacy organisation, says funding scarcity has fed into an attack on the rationale of groups to provide specialist services:
“In the past year we’ve seen the erosion of race equality on the political agenda and the emergence of a new ‘mainstreaming’ ideology which tries to apply a ‘one size fits all’ approach to voluntary and community sector funding. This has excluded groups without the voice to speak out.
“Disadvantaged BME communities rely on the unique knowledge and reach of specialist VCOs. But because these are small, underfunded organisations to begin with they are losing out to larger, well established organisations in the competition for funding.”
As funding dries up and a commissioning model replaces grants for VCOs, there is a growing concern that the needs of isolated, vulnerable women are being forgotten.












