A big fat problem for women
Most of us are aware that childhood obesity is at an all-time high, and eating disorders disproportionately affect women more than men.
Many organisations are doing great work in promoting healthy lifestyles, and are giving out good advice, but of all things to put on an advert, I don’t think it is this.
If you’re trying to change childhood obesity, it doesn’t take much common sense to decide that having a poster depicting an overweight young girl with the slogan “WARNING It’s hard to be a little girl when you’re not” is a bad idea.
It seems logical to me that in order to get people to listen to you, you don’t start by stigmatising and shaming them.
The advert, which advocates presupposed notions of what little girls are meant to be, or look like, has been causing a bit of a stir in the US.
This advert is part of the Strong4Life movement and was recently launched by a public health campaign started by Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta.
Despite being faced with much criticism, Doug Hertz, the Chairman of the Board of Trustees of Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta, remains firmly committed to the advert campaign.
In a piece he wrote for the Atlanta Journal Constitution, he stated: “We decided that these ads were necessary to get Georgia talking about how to make childhood obesity a priority. They have accomplished that goal”.
Georgia is high in the ranks of the most obese state in America, but surely, they could have come up with something less offensive to get people talking?
However, it is because of adverts such as these that the STANDards movement came into being.
American fat activist Marily Wann, frustrated with the treatment of fat people in society, started a collection of adverts which celebrated bodies of all shapes and sizes – without the patronising edge.
They don’t encourage obesity, nor do they shame people for being obese. Instead, they acknowledge that obesity develops due to different circumstances and ‘stand for health being about individuals, not size’.
Her collection raises an important point in the way society views bigger people.
Emphasis is continually put on the individual and how they can choose to eat more healthily, how they can choose a diet plan that suits them, how they can change their lives by dropping a dress size. To be honest, I think this is all a bit naïve.
I mean, look at how the economic cuts impacts on health. For those who are struggling financially, food available at an affordable price often has the highest fat content, meaning for many families obesity isn’t a life choice – it is a means of survival.
But by entering into the realm of putting all of the onus onto the individual, rather than looking, say, to the government and supermarkets for help, many individuals – especially women – end up feeling guilty and ashamed for fear of being judged.
You can’t sit through a TV break without watching an advert for some sort of diet or ‘perfect’ body, and another for chocolate or ice cream.
Surely this sends us contradictory messages? We should always be on a diet, or at least feel the need to go on one. But we should simultaneously be indulging ourselves in the finest calorific food available.
And if we’re not being surrounded by food adverts, we are being patronised with ‘plus size’ products. In many catalogues ‘plus size’ products start at size 14. With the average dress size in the UK being somewhere between 16 and 18, it seems absolutely ridiculous to start plus size at 14.
I come into the larger lady category myself and in my experience, have been patronised with comments such as “good on you for wearing a skirt” – as if there is a ban on such things. “Good on you for wearing colour” – as if all women who are size 16 plus must hide themselves in black tents.
As soon as society begins to realise that that instead of shaming the individual, we should be questioning the media, the government, food manufacturers and medicine, fat shaming will continue.
But for the time being, at least we have Marilyn Wann’s adverts to give us some faith.

















I think this is such a thorny issue and I agree completely that The Powers That Be are getting it wrong most of the time!
I’ve ranged between a (UK) size 18/20 and 8/10 myself and can atest that making me feel ‘bad’ for my size was not a motivating factor!
Although I agree with the comment about chocolate adverts, I also think we’re being bombarded by “Healthy” options everywhere we look. Most of them are not actually that healthy – for example the amount of sugar in Kelloggs Special K! (http://huff.to/x4Kqix)
My biggest bugbear is that we live in an age where portion sizes are bigger, unhealthy food is invariably the cheaper and almost always easier option and it’s practically impossible to buy one person servings (without paying a premium for the pleasure!).
Add to this the fact that at a time when everyone is complaining about expanding waistlines, they’re also raising the Recommended Daily Allowance for calories. Talk about mixed signals!
At the end of the day an indvidual’s weight is down to their actions, but society needs to recognise they have a part to play in educating and supporting people so that they can live healthily. Just making us feel guilty whilst confusing and, at times, lying outright to us, is simply not the solution.
Those ads make me want to weep. To anybody wanting to understand just how bizarre – and new – this whole thing about your body being ‘who you are’ I can only recommend Bodies by Susie Orbach: it really made me understand the whole issue of not only ‘obesity’ but of the obsession with body shape in general.
Did anybody see that programme on last night ‘Pushy and Proud: Diet Crazy Mums? Mothers foisting their weight issues on their children (oops! I mean daughters, of course); another thing that made me want to weep.