subscribe: Posts | Comments

Guardian puts Facebook’s ‘no nipples’ rule to the test

1 comment

Alexandra Szydlowska
WVoN co-editor

The Guardian is putting Facebook’s ‘no nipples’ censure to the test by posting photos of breastfeeding women on its Comment is Free Facebook page.

According to the Guardian’s contributor Rowan Davies, who announced the action yesterday:

“Facebook is one of the most influential cultural mediators in the world. In reflecting and promoting the belief that milky nipples are injurious to public morality, it gives succour to every shopping centre security guard who’s ever told a nursing mother to put it away or leave the premises.

“A mother who is told by Facebook that her breastfeeding photos have been removed because her nipples were showing is quite likely to be humiliated, upset and one step closer to giving up on breastfeeding.”

The move has attracted a mixed reaction among the newspaper’s readers, some of whom have decried the Guardian’s actions as “immature” and “low-quality journalism”.

Others, however, have supported the move as a protest against Facebook’s ever tightening censure of what can and cannot be published online.

Facebook has a history of categorising breastfeeding pictures as “obscene content”, in many cases taking down groups for “violating Facebook’s terms of service.”

Such actions have incensed users and sparked protests, to the extent that in the past the social networking site has been made to eat its words.

Earlier this year, Facebook apologised for deleting photos of young girls pretending to breastfeed after citing the images posted by Express Yourself Mums, an NHS-backed breastfeeding website, as a ‘policy violation’.

After finding the group removed, a campaign was sparked to put Express Yourself Mums back into action. The images and the group were reinstated but the argument against Facebook’s censure rage on.

Facebook has previously said that photos where a nipple or an areola can be seen are against its policy. It has since said that it usually removes breastfeeding photos only when complaints by other users are brought to its attention.

However, Facebook’s standard response against incensed users seems to be that the photos were taken down “in error”.

So where exactly does Facebook draw the line? In the latest (leaked) version of its content guidelines, Facebook has stated that “bodily fluids (except semen) are ok to show unless a human being is captured in the process.”

This seems to me like uncharacteristic leniency on Facebook’s part towards acts that (unlike breastfeeding) need not be publicised in support of a cause.

Unless there’s a Facebook group in support of urination that I have not come across yet.

Rules are there for a reason. However, there’s no ignoring the indignation a mother may feel on receiving a notification that their photograph has been deemed a violation of pornographic content rules.

Perhaps what is most needed is clarity. However, until Facebook decides to publish its content guidelines online for all to see, it’s anyone’s guess what will offend them next.

  1. vicki wharton says:

    What is really beginning to f**k me off about Facebook is the fact that its size and reach makes it akin to a media organisation, delivering cultural values and norms into peoples lives. Its arbitary rules about what it will and won’t show – no breastfeeding but pro rape – is really beginning to change what are acceptable social values. There is a reason that media organisations are required to have a license and be run by socially responsible people and the like of Murdoch and Facebook shaping society is frightening in their determination to undermine a just and equal society where people’s basic human rights and dignity are supported.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *