subscribe: Posts | Comments

Legislation is “only way” to get more women into UK boardrooms

4 comments

Alison Clarke
WVoN co-editor 

Just over a year ago today, Lord Davies of Abersoch produced a report about the lack of gender equality in Britain’s boardrooms.

It was not encouraging. Using the most recent figures (from 2010), he reported that women made up only 12.5 per cent of board members of FTSE 100 companies.

At that rate of change, he reckoned that it would take over 70 years to achieve gender-balanced boardrooms.

Things have improved slightly over the past year, with the result that the figures have now inched their way up the scale to 15.2 per cent, according to Board Watch.

So what needs to happen to speed things up?  Quotas, according to Averil Leimon, director of leadership consultancy, the White Water Group. She says we need a “paradigm shift” to get things moving and the only way to do that is through legislation.

“Take the example of seat belts,” she says. “The campaign to get people wearing them relied on logic and statistics to begin with.

“That didn’t work so the government moved onto appealing to our emotions, with images of peaches being smashed by hammers to indicate what would happen to us if we continued to resist.

“That didn’t work either so eventually they introduced a law which changed our behaviour almost overnight. Now, we automatically get in our cars and put our seat belts on.

“It was a behavioural change and that’s what it’s going to take to improve women’s representation on boards.”

And it seems that more and more women agree with her. Although initially (and sometimes still publicly) resistant to the idea,  women in business are beginning to see the light, she says.

“I’ve noticed that over the last year, when I talk to senior women leaders and mention the “q” word, they still recoil in horror to begin with, but once I set out the business case and tell them the stats, the change is remarkable”.

That made her start to wonder, a year on after the Davies report, whether she could find out what more of these women really thought about the state of Britain’s boardrooms.

So White Water Group polled the leaders of  30 corporate women’s networks representing more than 10,000 women at some of Britain’s leading firms.

And the results were surprising. Far from shying away from the idea of quotas, almost two thirds of those asked (64.5 per cent) said that quotas were needed to achieve the target set by Davies of 25 per cent of women on boards by 2015.

The same percentage said that the Davies report had not improved opportunities for women in their own companies.

But even if the government introduces quotas (and prime minister David Cameron hinted earlier this month that he might), Leimon  says that more is needed to change the culture in companies.

“We also have to convince the men at the top of the need for change. They can make a difference as they are the ones in the positions of power, so we need to convince them to sponsor and promote women”.

That should not be difficult, she argues, given the clear business case for change.

“We’ve shown that businesses with equal numbers of men and women at the senior management level are more profitable than businesses with predominantly male leaders.

“What’s more, demographic shifts mean that by 2030 the UK will be short of 1.3m people of leadership age. More women in senior management would address both these issues.”

Whatever way you look at things, the lack of women in leadership represents a “serious waste of talent. If we were to squander any other resource in the same way, shareholders would be asking some very challenging questions.

“So perhaps” she says “it’s about time they asked themselves where all the women are”.

  1. Why is it always ‘leadership consultants’, ‘life/career coaches’ and recruitment agencies who support quotas? No real business leaders seem to have given them their public backing yet.

    Personally, I think they are demeaning and drive a coach and horses through meritocracy.

  2. Jane Da Vall says:

    The City Women’s Network supports quotas. They all earn their living in the City, and we look around and see.

  3. You’re right, it does.

    But only if we lived in a meritocracy.

  4. @Karen absolutely!

    I find myself fuming at the language used when discussing this topic.

    There seems to be this belief that business will in some way find a ‘natural’ and ‘fair’ equilibrium if left alone.

    In that case, that women are unable to make it to the top must be as a result of their inability to make it that far, not the failure of a male-dominated system putting barrier after barrier in their path.

    Quotas won’t ruin the imagined meritocracy, quotas won’t give women an unfair advantage. Quotas will go some way to forcing the system and society to recognise that they are overlooking 50% of the workforce for reasons that have nothing to do with merit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *