subscribe: Posts | Comments

Standing in the (Louboutin) shoes of Asma al-Assad

0 comments

Jackie Gregory
WVoN co-editor 

When your partner’s day job includes the mass slaughter of his own citizens, what is a woman to do?

Speak out and stand up for those who cannot speak – or get online and salivate over a whacking great pair of Christian Louboutin’s?

As Bashir al-Assad, the president of Syria, went on a killing rampage, his British-born wife Asma al-Assad indulged in an enthusiastic shopping spree.

This is according to emails leaked to The Guardian, considered genuine but which cannot be 100 per cent validated.

In one, al-Assad apparently chatted about 16 inch heels which cost $5,000 and ordered chandeliers and bespoke cabinets from Paris.

Clearly it’s abhorrent and indefensible  –  the actions of a deluded Marie Antoinette.

But the very uncomfortable question in all of this is: how would we ourselves react in her shoes?

Some say she is a serious-minded and loving mother who is trapped in a gilded cage, a puppet herself of the regime, whose survival tactic is to stand by her man.

A former acquaintance, Brigid Keenan, told ITN news that she could not condemn al-Assad, 36,  because she did not know her circumstances.  She said that the president’s wife seemed like a nice woman, who was very much in love with her husband.

Keenan said: “I am very surprised that she hasn’t left but it might be impossible for her to leave but I don’t know what her circumstances are and I wouldn’t want to judge.”

Others are swift to stamp on this kind of reaction as apologist and say categorically, no matter her personal circumstances, al-Assad should have had the moral stamina to speak up a long time ago.  Just as ordinary Syrians have tried to do.

Indeed the leaked emails suggest that Mayassa al-Thani, daughter of the emir of Qatar urged her to stop being in denial.

“The opportunity for real change and development was lost a long time ago. Nevertheless, one opportunity closes, others open up – and I hope it’s not too late for reflection and coming out of the state of denial.”

In another email in January, she urged al-Assad to leave.

“In all honesty – looking at the tide of history and the escalation of recent events – we’ve seen two results – leaders stepping down or getting asylum or leaders being brutally attacked.

“I think this is a good opportunity to leave and restart a normal life. I am sure you have many places to turn to, including Doha.”

Historian Gaia Servadio, who worked with al-Assad on an arts project, is clear that she should have spoken up.

“She was very much, as we would say, left wing. She (created) a very, very good impression.  She seemed to be very bright, very respectful of others,” said Servadio, in an article by Maria Golovnina for Reuters.

“It’s a very nasty regime … Thousands of people have been killed.  So it’s very difficult to say:  poor woman.  She certainly should have found a way to talk.”

Now al-Assad, her mother-in-law and two sister-in-laws, have been hit with European Union (EU) sanctions, which means there will be no more gilded baubles from Paris.  They cannot travel on the continent and their assets have been frozen.

However as al-Assad holds British citizenship, there is nothing stopping her from coming to the UK where her parents still live.

Known as Emma in her younger life, Asma Akhras was born and brought up in a comfortable home in west London.  Her father was a Harley Street cardiologist.

After attending an independent school, she completed a degree in computer science at Kings College, London in 1996, during which time she met Bashir al-Assad who was in the capital studying ophthalmology. She then worked for JP Morgan as an investment banker.

Bashir al-Assad ‘s destiny to follow his father as president was sealed when his brother Basil, the heir,  was killed in a car crash.  The couple married in 2000 and moved to Syria and now have three children Hafez, 10; Zain 8; and Kareem 7.

At first al-Assad was viewed as a reformist, with Vogue magazine describing her as a ‘rose in the desert’.  She won a number of international awards for her work advocating women’s and children’s rights and promoting rural development.

But in the past year this image has changed. Theodore Dalrymple, author of Spoilt Rotten: Toxic Sentimentality, talks in The Telegraph about her  ‘metamorphosis from Mrs Assad to Eva Peron and then to Elena Ceausescu’ .

Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely, a famous quote of Edward Dalberg Acton in 1887.  In the court of al-Assad, Dalrymple argues that power not only corrupts but insulates from reality.

“Bad actions are rationalised as necessary and then even as good,” he says.

In one revealing email, al-Assad allegedly jokes that she is the ‘real dictator’.  In a discussion with a friend about their spouses, The Telegraph reports her saying : “As for listening – I am the REAL dictator, he has no choice …” she wrote on Dec 14.

But it seems that she has chosen not to use her voice to stop her husband slaughtering Syrians.

Instead she has retreated into sentimentalism and justification.  On Mother’s Day, she met with mothers who had lost children to the rebels.

The Guardian reports her as telling them: “If the father goes the foundation of the home is lost, but if the mother goes, the heart of the home is lost with her.”

We may rightly stand and condemn but a second question:  Has the world’s response been much different to Asma al-Assad’s?

While the killings have gone on, we have continued to shop, preferring to pay more attention to our own material needs, the plight of the Syrians are in our consciousness for about as long as the TV news report lasts and then we move on to something else.

Countries have made their excuses about why no firmer stance has been taken against the regime. There seems to be a delusional wish that it would all go away quietly.

We empathise, sympathise but as world citizens, the vast majority of us have so far failed to truly speak out or take action.

There’s something rotten in the state of Syria, there could well be something rotten in the heart of Asma al-Assad, but the stench has no borders, and there is something rancid with the response of the rest of the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *