subscribe: Posts | Comments

Lonely Hearts Club not for women?

3 comments

Deborah Cowan
WVoN co-editor

In June 1967, English pop artist Sir Peter Blake created cultural history when he co-designed perhaps the most iconic album cover of all time – that of the Beatles ‘Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band’.

Arguably, the album cover has reached equitable artistic standing due to its instant recognisability leading to it being parodied again and again by the likes of The Ruttles, The Simpsons and Frank Zappa.

The original cover for Sgt. Pepper features life-size cardboard cut outs of some of the people most admired by the Beatles at the time – in excess of sixty 2-D models of the great and the good make an appearance.

They include Albert Einstein, Edgar Allan Poe, Bob Dylan, Aldous Huxley, Oscar Wilde, George Bernard Shaw, Dylan Thomas – even Fred Astaire, WC Fields and Laurel and Hardy seem fitting choices amongst such distinguished company.

But  what of the female contingent ?

Well, here a different pattern emerges, Mae West, Marilyn Monroe, Marlene Dietrich, Diana Dors and – rather confusingly in such grown up company – Shirley Temple.

Whilst the significance and power of these women should not be diminished or understated in any way we have to ask why these five women in particular were chosen?

Ms Temple aside, the answer may seem all too obvious,  they were the biggest sex symbols of their time.

Had feminism fallen off the map?

Cut to 45 years later, and the latest incarnation of the album cover comes once again courtesy of Sir Peter Blake.

The new design is entitled ‘Family Friends and Icons’ and was released this week to mark his 80th birthday.

It’s very much in keeping with the original, except that he has replaced John, Paul, Ringo and George with his own wife and daughters, and there are now 18 other female figures represented from a total of 79, a slight improvement.

Sir Peter’s choices include Delia Smith and Fanny Craddock, Stella McCartney, Vivienne Westwood, Mary Quant, Twiggy and Kate Moss, by way of Audrey Hepburn, Helen Mirren and Shirley Bassey.

Let’s not dwell on the fact that a majority of these women are known because of how they look, or how they make other women look.

But if the poster was redesigned to simply include icons in the feminist field, would any of these women make the cut?

One doesn’t have to think too hard for the most obvious choices to come bursting forth in an epic roll call – Virginia Woolf, Gloria Steinem, Emmeline Pankhurst, Benazir Bhutto, Rosa Parks, Aung San Suu Kyi, Marilyn French, Germaine Greer, Corazon Aquino, Eleanor Roosevelt, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Mary Wollstonecraft………….

A veritable powerhouse of warrior women.

Yet what has happened to the ‘now’ generation?  Where are the feminist icons of today?  What does a 2012 feminist look like?

If I were to make just one suggestion, it would be perhaps the most hotly debated figure on the modern feminist horizon – Lady Gaga.

Ms Gaga herself is contradictory on the matter, one minute saying, “I’m not a feminist – I hail men, I love men. I celebrate American male culture, and beer, and bars and muscle cars…” and the next saying that she is in fact a feminist, and making indisputably feminist statements: “When I say to you, there is nobody like me, and there never was, that is a statement I want every woman to feel and make about themselves.”

While she makes her mind up, perhaps we need to ask whether she is an asset to the struggle for the advancement of the women’s movement and for female empowerment.

Yes, she sometimes parades in her pants, but she uses her sexuality in a powerful ‘don’t mess with me’ kind of way.

And she dresses in an absurdly idiosyncratic fashion that has no description because it simply hasn’t been done before.  It doesn’t always win her complimentary column inches, but frankly my dear, she doesn’t give a damn.  Perhaps therein lies her greatest power.

After the famous Gaga meat-dress incident, British journalist Kira Cochrane asked in The Guardian, ‘Is she a brilliant performance artist – or an empty provocateur? Is she driven by ideas, or neediness? Is she a feminist icon, or just a slightly offbeat sex object?’

I have a few questions of my own which I think may help to clarify my choice:

Does she challenge traditional notions of gender and sexuality? Absolutely she does.  Does she support the sexual empowerment of women?  In spades.

Is she herself a powerful woman, unhindered by male opinion or authority?  Oh yes. Does she always present a good role model for the feminists of tomorrow? Well, that’s another debate altogether.

While I would definitely put Ms Gaga on my feminist album cover, up front and centre, I know that not everyone would agree with me, including, probably, Sir Peter Blake.

The fact that she is not shy of baring a yard of flesh or three – be it hers or that of some unfortunate bovine – should not really be the point.

Lady Gaga clearly uses her sexuality and her body in the name of popular music.   But does this mean she can’t use the F word? Does a woman have to cover up to be a feminist icon?  Discuss.

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I would say that any woman that has to take her clothes off to get noticed is not a feminist icon but can still be a feminist. Lady G said of her early days that she was getting nowhere, until she stripped down to her undies to sing and then she got noticed. The problem is that women don’t make the rules as to what men notice about women, men do. The more they see women becoming equal in the workplace, the more they have sought to portray us as bitches and whores. Does that make sense?

    • I think it makes a lot of sense. It seems ironic that in a time when women are supposed to be pushing for better pay, greater respect etc. and are in theory, closer to equality than ever before, that the number of women are have to use their bodies to get ahead, if it hasn’t risen, it certainly hasn’t decreased or improved. While I respect Lady Gaga as a feminist, and I’m not denying that she is one, I find it a little disheartening to think that the most well known ‘feminist icon’ of today is a woman who has to strip down to her undies in order to gain the respect, status and power she needs in order to be a feminist icon and inspire other women. While obviously I know there are plenty of inspirational feminists who don’t use this route to get their message across but they just don’t have the same kind of world publicity as she does. A little sad, in my view.

      • vicki wharton says:

        I’m not sure that women are getting closer to equality than ever before – I get the feeling that the tide is beginning to roll back and we are going to have to fight to hang on to every inch we gained in the sixties, 70s and 80s. America is challenging abortion laws left right and centre and Wisconsin has just repealed equal pay legislation and there are 120 million missing females in China, India and Far East according to UN. Meanwhile in the UK 1 in 3 girls suffers sexist violence at school and 1 in 4 women sexist violence in the home and 9 out of 10 rape victims do not report their attacker due to sexist discrimination in the ‘justice’ system, caused by rigging of the electorate by the media, especially on line porn. Sorry to be a doom monger, but that doesn’t feel like we’re making headway, feels more like a lot of women have been diverted into the bedroom rather than the boardroom.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *