Controversial legal aid bill passed by Lords
Yesterday evening the British government’s controversial Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill was finally passed in the House of Lords.
The bill, having been defeated a total of 14 times, has raised concerns over changes to the way it deals with victims of domestic abuse.
Earlier this week, the Observer newspaper reported that an alliance of women’s groups (including Mumsnet and the Women’s Institute) had written to Kenneth Clarke, justice secretary, regarding changes to the bill relaxing legal aid restrictions for only those women who enter a refuge.
Recent research shows that of the 124,895 women who requested support for domestic violence only just over 17,000 went to refuges.
The letter said “We know from our work with victims of violence that women most often seek shelter and comfort from family and friends after experiencing violence; a natural and understandable reaction to a traumatic situation.”
Other concerns have been raised, particularly in relation to the amount of time between the crime and the claim being made, which the government has reduced to 12 months.
Lady Scotland of Asthal, a Labour peer and former attorney general, earlier this week requested amendments to allow evidence admissible for up to six years after the crime in cases of domestic abuse.
She said there had been a “narrower gateway” for evidence in the past and “lives had been lost.
“We on this side of the house have made a choice – our choice is to support victims and their children.
“While we have a situation where many, many women do not have the support they need, we cannot close our eyes.”
However, it appears that this amendment was not in the final bill agreed yesterday.
Justice Minister Lord McNally said that the government had agreed to widen the definition of domestic violence and that legal aid would be made available “even in older instances of domestic violence”.
A spokesperson for Sound Off for Justice, a group campaigning against the bill said:
“For over a year, we have warned the impact of this cut will not be to save money but to leave thousands of victims with no way of escape. The government knows this is an attack on the family and on women.”












