subscribe: Posts | Comments

How can America claim to be the champion of democracy?

1 comment

Aliyyah Ahad
Freelance writer 

Earlier this month, the US Supreme Court decided to uphold a law which subjects anyone arrested for even a minor violation to a strip search.

An apparent triumph of security over privacy, the ruling came as a surprise to many.

But isn’t it obvious? If you haven’t paid your speeding ticket or gotten your license renewed, it’s probably because you are on drugs. These being the same drugs that the police will no doubt discover before putting you behind bars.

If it isn’t drugs that have encouraged you to avoid paying your dues, it is most likely that you have a weapon. For why else would you feel that you are above the law?

The issues at stake in this debate are the right to privacy and the severity of crime that invalidates that right. Strip searches are both humiliating and degrading and should not be used as a standard procedure.

The four liberal judges on the Supreme Court voted against the law while the five conservative judges voted in favour of it.

Interestingly, Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, who wrote the majority opinion in the ruling, noted that there are many definitions of “strip search”. The Supreme Court took close visual inspection without touching as its measure. This is because a close visual inspection with touching is a sexual assault.

It was this ruling, which occurred in what we like to consider the world’s champion of democracy, that immediately ran through my mind when I read about virginity testing in Egyptian prisons.

When the military arrested 190 demonstrators in Tahrir Square on March 9, 2011, many of the detainees were women.

A prison military doctor, Ahmed Adel, performed “virginity tests” on the unmarried women. This involved exposing their genitals and using his fingers to examine their hymens.

Despite evidence that these tests were a routine procedure for women entering Egyptian prisons, the military insisted that the doctor was acting of his own accord and not following a military procedure.

The military prosecutor initially charged Adel with sexual assault. However, only five days later this charge was reduced to committing “an act of public indecency” and  he was ultimately acquitted.

Rape and other serious charges are treated very severely when committed by civilians. Sentences range from 25 years to the death penalty.

When the perpetrator is a member of the military, on the other hand, the same crime can be punishable by only three years in prison. Clearly there is a huge miscarriage of justice where the military is concerned.

But how does this relate to the American case?

It’s quite simple – it should make us ask to what extent one must violate the law in order to be deemed not to deserve its protection.

The women in Tahrir Square were protesters.Is the expression of free speech and the right to assemble also a crime in America?

The Occupy protesters can attest to the fact that this is now reality. Should you be subjected to humiliating practices when your only crime is challenging the status quo?

Is the role of the police to protect and serve or to arrest and debase?

It is not clear that this law is serving the interests of the people, be they totally or only partially law-abiding.

Just as we would denounce the virginity tests in Egypt, we should not overlook the rights that can no longer be taken for granted in the US.

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I have noticed the police in the UK seeming to take a dim view of the public’s right to protest at various anti establishment rallies – think this is a world wide problem with the state machine being used more and more to protect the property and civil rights of the rich/famous rather than the general population. Hence constant draconian fines for minor infringements of traffic/parking laws, and a tax on fraudulent banking practices to try and offset the damage caused by the next huge banking fraud – would seem a better idea to stamp out fraud rather than tax it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *