Sexual health services under attack in Texas – again
Polly Trenow
WVoN co-editor
The future of America’s leading sexual and reproductive health care provider was plunged into uncertainty in Texas once again this week.
Planned Parenthood celebrated a short lived victory on Monday night when a US District Judge, Lee Yeakel, ruled that it was unconstitutional to stop the charity from participating in the Texas Women’s Health Program, which serves about 130,000 low-income women.
But the following evening a federal appeals court Judge, Jerry Smith, agreed to an emergency motion from Texas to stay Judge Yeakel’s injunction, pending an appeal.
This is the latest twist in an ongoing dispute between the state of Texas and Planned Parenthood.
In 2005 the state ruled that no state funds could go to clinics that performed or promoted abortions.
Last year the Republican-controlled legislature passed a further law forbidding state agencies from providing funds to an organisation affiliated with abortion providers.
The eight Planned Parenthood clinics that didn’t provide abortions sued the state claiming the law unconstitutionally restricted their freedom of speech and association.
At the time Patricio Gonzales, CEO of Planned Parenthood Association of Hidalgo County accused the state of foul play and called on Governor Rick Perry and the state to “put Texan women first and set aside any vendetta they may have against Planned Parenthood.”
“No woman should ever have to fear being cut off from her doctor’s care because of shortsighted political games” Gonzales said.
Following the 2011 Texas law, the Department of Health and Human Services withdrew all Medicaid funding for family planning to the state.
They argued that the state had broken federal Medicaid rules by discriminating against qualified family planning providers and would therefore lose the entire program, which provides cancer screenings, contraceptives and basic health care to 130,000 low-income women each year.
Planned Parenthood triumphed briefly this Monday when District Judge Yeakel stated that the law was unconstitutional because it barred eight Planned Parenthood clinics that don’t provide abortions from participating in the program based on their affiliation with legally and financially separate entities that offer abortions.
The judge accepted Planned Parenthood’s argument that banning the organisation from the program would leave hundreds of thousands of women without access to clinics for basic health services and check-ups.
“By requiring plaintiffs to certify that they do not ‘promote’ elective abortions and that they do not ‘affiliate’ with entities that perform or promote elective abortions … Texas is reaching beyond the scope of the government program and penalizing plaintiffs for their protected conduct,” Yeakel wrote in his order.
However, within 24 hours Judge Smith upheld an emergency motion filed by the State of Texas which, at least temporarily, overturned the ruling in favour of Planned Parenthood.
This type of legal action is rare and Judge Smith has come under criticism for mixing politics with the law by issuing a two-sentence decision on his own, with no explanation.
No one from the Texas Planned Parenthood was available for comment at the time of going to press.












