subscribe: Posts | Comments

Are women more left wing than men?

0 comments

women's voting patterns, government policies, women's rightsPolls suggest that women are showing greater support for the left.

So, are political attitudes shifting? Or is this pattern a reaction to a government which has been unable to address the modern needs and interests of women?

The gender gap in voting intention predicates the ‘women’s vote’ as an important political tool in party campaigning, and this has been a strong theme in the run up to this year’s election.

The Conservatives’ diminishing support among women has differed with Labour’s ostensible surge in popularity, which most recently saw young women ignite the #Milifandom campaign in defense of the physical and political attributes of Ed Miliband.

Opinion polls after the first televised debate in March reflected gendered differences in performance evaluations.

Nigel Farage ranked 9 points lower among women who significantly favoured the performances of the three female, minority party leaders: Sturgeon (+5), Bennett (+9) and Wood (+11).

Voter intention polls again produced gender divides, with Labour and the Green Party more popular among women, and UKIP and the Conservatives rating higher among men.

The polls suggest that right wing parties tend to rate more favourably among men, and women appear to show greater support for parties on the left, but does this correlation infer that women are more left wing?

This pattern has been found in several OECD countries in recent years and has manifested in the US since the 1980s, where women’s support for the Democrats has substantially outweighed that for the Republicans.

This theory becomes more convincing when the aggregated data is classified in accordance with intersecting political cleavages like age.

A 2014 YouGov poll showed young women in particular to be moving further to the left, favouring Labour, while UKIP fell behind.

Older generations reflect the inverse: both men and women seem to be aligning with parties on the right.

The notion that women might be more left wing is a fairly modern one. For many years, women in the UK were more likely to vote for the Conservative party, which had invested in the idea of the family, and created a role for women in the home; an increasingly politicised and masculinised Labour party was largely representative of the working class male.

However, during the 1970s and the 1980s, women’s role in the home and the workplace began to change, and during the 1990s, Labour began to mobilise around women’s interests like healthcare and education.

This change was consolidated in the election of 101 women MPs to the House of Commons in 1997, and institutionalised in the creation of roles like the Minister for Women.

The Conservatives have since tried to feminise, to largely unconvincing effect.

Under the Coalition government, only three of the party’s seventeen cabinet ministers are women, and outside parliament women have been disproportionately affected by austerity measures in practically every sector.

The Fair Deal For Women campaign reported that women have shouldered 79 per cent of the government’s so-called ‘deficit repayments’, which have been approached through cuts to public spending such as child benefits, housing benefits and tax credits.

When one in four women are in low paid work and when nine out of ten lone parents are women, the notion that women may be more left wing seems almost inextricable from the gendered impacts of austerity.

Left wing ideologies typically assume a more welfare-led approach to governance, with greater focus on issues of social justice and equality.

Therefore, women’s voting intentions are likely to be heavily influenced by party policy on priority issues like childcare, the NHS and the deficit, and this may not be indicative of shifting political attitudes as such.

For all parties, women are still largely identified as a homogenous group, with a single set of issues, revolving predominantly around the family, education and health.

These issues have been found to be priority concerns for many women, but this limited mandate reflects gendered understandings and assumptions of women’s role and interests, which are determined by an archaic social order, which parties are only just starting to modernise in areas like LGBT rights.

Failure to acknowledge the many cleavages intersecting with gender, like age, race, religion or class, results in the underrepresentation or exclusion of so many women and men from political discourse.

The ‘women’s vote’ thus remains a symbolic one; mobilised as political capital as a reflection of progressive politics.

To suggest that women are more left wing than men may hold elements of truth, but this statement risks framing the situation inaccurately.

Gender divides on the political spectrum are less a reflection of deeply held and renegotiated political philosophies, and more a response to governments which have made living conditions for women much worse, and which fail to recognise that gender is one identity marker among many which define individuals and differentiate the electorate.

If women are siding with the left, it is because there is space there for more progressive, inclusive politics with parties that are increasingly gender balanced and representative of women’s divergent interests and needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *