subscribe: Posts | Comments

Better support needed for women seeking asylum

0 comments

women refugees, UK, house of lords report‘One of the things that is most lacking is dignity.’

Imagine suffering at the hands of your husband, uncle, brother or father.

Imagine being raped, beaten and subjugated by your country’s offcials, and having nowhere to turn, or being persecuted for your political beliefs.

And imagine escaping.

Imagine making an arduous, often treacherous journey to a better, safer place.

And imagine the despair when you reach that place and you find that, apparently, the system there too couldn’t care less, and in some instances is pitched against you from the start.

Women who are seeking asylum in the UK are often not provided with adequate information on their rights when they arrive.

Often they are required to recount their ordeals to male translators, or in front of their children, even if this involves describing appalling sexual or domestic violence.

This means that they are less likely to predent their full story for their claim assessment – and risk being deported.

The Protection Gap campaign, run by Asylum Aid, has been addressing these issues, and has so far seen some success – including a Home Office Women’s Asylum Protection Plan.

However, we still hear of incidents of mistreatment of women at detention centres like Yarl’s Wood where women are reporting incidences of intimidation and violations of privacy by male staff.

The recent Report of the Inquiry into the Use of Immigration Detention in the United Kingdom by the UK government’s All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Migration concluded that the UK ‘uses detention disproportionately and inappropriately,’ and that that detention of asylum seekers is ‘seriously detrimental to the individuals who are detained in terms of their mental and physical well-being, as well as hugely costly to the taxpayer.’

The report has recommended a maximum time limit of 28 days of detention, and the implementation of ‘a robust system for receiving the decision to detain early in the period of detention’.

It also recommends that decisions to detain should be very rare and detention should be for the shortest possible time and only to effect removal and that the Government should learn from international best practice and introduce a much wider range of alternatives to detention than are currently used in the UK.

The proposed steps outlined by Asylum Aid, to give women seeking asylum the same rights as other women in order to facilitate accurate assessments, clearly fall within these recommendations. But there is still a long way to go.

At grass roots level there are initiatives that provide much-needed support and aid for these women. Women for Refugee Women were recently able to take a small number of women refugees on a short respite break, and the Migrant Artists Mutual Aid (MAMA) choir, based in Liverpoo,l uses performance and art to raise awareness of women’s experiences, and raise money for migrants in crisis.

There are many small initiatives across the UK that are making big differences to many women. However, they are still small islands in a sea of apathy and real change is needed from the top for any significant difference to be made.

Remarking on the inquiry during a House of Lords debate on the report last month, Baroness Ruth Lister said: ‘What became clear during the inquiry was the disconnect between official policy and what actually happens.

‘The current Home Office guidance that detention should be used sparingly and for the shortest possible period is rendered ineffective by working practices and culture.’

And Baroness Sally Hamwee, who, with Lister, was on the inquiry panel, said: The case management model used in Sweden is based on early intervention and a welfare and rights framework. Individuals feel that they are given a fair hearing – and if they have to leave, they can make their own arrangements with dignity.

‘This inquiry has said to me, among other things, that one of the things that is most lacking is dignity.’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *