Just who is Amanda Knox?
By Kerry Crowdy
It’s probably not a great idea to decide on someone’s innocence or guilt when they are being tried for a brutal murder (unless you’re a member of the jury). But it’s just about impossible to watch the gripping trial of Amanda Knox and not have an opinion. This has no doubt been fuelled by the intense media speculation that has surrounded her throughout the trial. Speculation that has become accepted as truth, abortion almost as integral to the case as the evidence itself.
Of course, shop the sexual assault and brutal murder of Meredith Kercher has disturbed and saddened the world. But it is the portrayal of this tragic event through the life of Amanda Knox that is the most alarming, because instead of focusing on hard evidence (of which there is very little), the media have gone into a frenzy over Knox’s private life. Whether solid truth or embroidered fantasy, it is not only of no relevance to the case, it is of no help whatsoever in elucidating the facts.
Indeed, the tantalising (but rumoured) details of Knox’s life have been crawled over by every medium imaginable. Type her name into an internet search engine, and thousands of results pop up, from lewd chat rooms to highbrow newspaper articles. It seems that Knox cannot escape the image that has been decided for her. And whilst she may very well be guilty of murder, it is hardly a crime to be a young, liberated woman. Would her lifestyle be of any interest to the world had she not been on trial? Even if so, is the world really so prudish, is her life really so scandalous? Or do we have a case of the media clutching at straws?
Paul Harris, who wrote an article on the case in The Observer agrees, stating “Almost everything can be used to paint a damning picture or, with a different analysis, can look entirely innocent. Even the nickname "Foxy Knoxy" fits into this category. In the initial rush of coverage, the moniker was used to portray Knox as a wanton woman. In fact, friends say, it hailed from her wily skills playing football for her university team.” Despite this, there has been no open-minded analysis of Knox’s character. The media, it seems, want to believe the worst.
Take an online report by The Daily Mail as a good example. There are tales spun of Knox’s rebellious past, detailing sordid encounters with strangers after touching down in Rome when she allegedly “e-mailed a former Washington University student, writing excitedly of having sex with a stranger on a train”. Then there’s her double life – ”although achieving top grades at university, she had started smoking potent “skunk” cannabis regularly and declared to friends that her favourite "poison" was vodka”. And most damning of all, her fiendish creative life – she posted a story on her MySpace page about how a young man drugs and rapes a young woman after remarking that "chicks just don't know what they want".
These details are tied into the murder of course (with this and every story) by subtle, but loaded implications. “Could it all have been prevented if more notice had been taken of the warning signs about Knox's increasingly erratic behaviour in Seattle? It seems unlikely”, asks the Daily Mail. And (paired with a haunting conclusion) ”a British family is left to mourn the brutal death of their beautiful daughter, who, it seems, died for no other reason than that she had the terrible misfortune to find herself sharing an apartment with 'Foxy' Knoxy”. Such connections operate to powerfully imply her almost unequivocal guilt.
Kercher, on the other hand, is presented as a virtuous and idealised woman. She has been described as “morally innocent” a “young woman with a desire to live” and perhaps best described by her sister, Stephanie Kercher, as "such a genuine person that when you think of her now and see her friends, you don't need to say anything, you only need to smile…As anyone who was lucky enough to have known her would testify, she was one of the most beautiful, intelligent, witty and caring people you could wish to meet.”
As such, Kercher presents a useful antithesis to Knox’s image, providing reporters with simplistic dichotemies - saint or sinner, victim or villain, Madonna or Whore. The Observer has (thankfully) highlighted a more positive picture of Knox, noting that she “has become a focus for condemnation of the free-wheeling ways of youngsters abroad, dabbling in sex and drugs. She was the strong-willed, promiscuous American with a dark side that may have turned to murder in search of erotic thrills.”
These all or nothing extremes are a symbol of the attitude towards women in the news, rarely taking the facts and evidence into consideration, and instead focusing on hearsay and falsities. Falsities that could influence Amanda Knox’s current trial and have terrible implications for her future.
As if more proof were needed of the press’s obsession with Knox, there has been little or no coverage of her former boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, and the third member of the ”orgy of death” (all acknowledgements to the Sun for that one) Rudy Guede, who has already been jailed for the crime. Although suspects in the trial just as much as Knox, there has been nothing even close to the intense fascination and speculation that has surrounded her.
Could it be that the story that has been weaved around Knox has nothing to do with her alleged crime, and everything to do with her youth, looks and alleged sexual appetite? Could it be that the media can only view women as objects that don’t exist as themselves, but instead must be transformed into symbols, in this case the Madonna and the Whore?
It is true that there are disturbing reports by police and witnesses that Knox ”cart wheeled” and "did the splits" while waiting to be questioned. That surely erases the image of the ”femme fatale” to be replaced by someone suddenly childlike, young and certainly unable to deal with the complicated goings-on surrounding her. Like a child, incapable of containing her emotions, whether naughty or good, innocent or guilty, this behaviour demonstrates what is most troubling and unsettling about the case – the fact that the reality of her actions could not be further from the contrived illusion of Knox. Her behaviour is contradictory and complicated, and until a verdict has been reached, she will remain a figure of intense fascination and speculation.
But the most important point of all in this sad tale, as Candace Dempsey (quoted in the Observer) has said is that: "Knox should never have been the centre of the trial. The person who died should have been the real story.” Because ultimately, this story is not a scandalous piece of gossip, but a harrowing loss of a young life. The almost barbaric manipulation of Knox has not only tainted her image, but has grievously tainted the memory of Meredith Kercher. She needs to be remembered as the tragic victim of a brutal murder, not as a shadowed character in a savage media conspiracy about another young woman, Amanda Knox.
















I was so very interested to read Kerry Crowdy’s article about Amanda Knox as seen from a youthful point of view.
So much of what we read in the daily newspapers only seems to be concerned with sensationalism from the point of view of the well-weathered reporting machines which the media use these days, and centered (it seems to me) purely on the need to sell more papers, rather than breaking down the true realities of these complex cases.
Well done indeed to Kerry – I look forward to hearing her comments about things in the future.