Feminine cooking (yes, there is such a thing) is “heroic, creative, practical and above all nurturing”
The concept of feminine cooking is a new one on me, but food writer Rose Prince argues in her new book, Kitchenella that it is “heroic, creative, practical and above all nurturing”.
She argues that because so few women cook nowadays (given that we’re all too busy working, caring for children and doing the housework), food education is left to television. And, with television cookery dominated by male chefs, feminine cookery is in danger of disappearing from the mainstream.
The few women given prime time by the broadcasters must play the role of pouting goddess or headmistress demanding obedience rather than practical mother cook. Stereotypical male traits characterise the chef shows; we watch generals in command, not home cooks in action.
If the chaps are not out there hunter gathering or demonstrating extraordinary technical prowess with a pig’s extremities, they are going head to head in gladiatorial combat in contests where the weakest have no chance of survival. It is cooking for show, not showing how to cook, and sometimes it is just bullying, dressed up as fun.
Knowing what it is like to manage a full-time job, children and a small budget is something a celebrity can only pretend to understand. But cookery shows are about entertainment: nurturing cookery is a reality show too far perhaps. Too simple, too modest, far too unexpecting of applause – yet to me, feminine food is the finest you can eat, whether at home or out in those restaurants where it finds a marginal place.
I can see her point about macho cookery programmes, but I’m really not sure about the concept of “feminine” cooking that nurtures. I’m also not sure about her point that “food education” is left to television – has she not heard of food technology which is taught in schools or am I just being dense?
You can read the full story in the Telegraph.
















I understand where she’s coming from. I don’t see cooking shows as instrumental in understanding how to manage one’s daily affairs within the kitchen, but rather a “how to” on various technical issues (recipes, techniques, etc.). I won’t touch reality television, and I understand just what kind of bullying she means, based on the commercials I’ve seen.
However, I would say that perhaps “feminine” cooking isn’t necessary the right word. Such a word comes from a societally ingrained view of mother-in-the-kitchen, but as we know, it’s not always mom, or a woman, who cooks.
There are many types of people in kitchens at home that don’t have neat little dishes for each ingredient; who’s going to wash all of those? There are instead, the consummate kitchen witches making magic with a few ordinary ingredients; men and women planning meals for their families, fending off children’s desire for junk food between meals, and handling the grumpy attitudes when a delectable meal is groaned over because the choices don’t appeal despite the mastery of flavors and pairings. Grandmothers teaching secrets about what foods heal what ailments (it’s not always chicken soup), uncles who make that one special dish that sets everyone talking at the family gathering.
I think what she’s suggesting is that there’s more to food and cooking than any cooking show can express. Nurturing is more than nourishment of the body, and it goes beyond cutting the crusts off of a child’s sandwich (the nutrients are in the crust!). There is a spirit, a soul, and a magic about daily cooking that does not come across. All the old secrets, the traditional knowledge, is not represented on television (although there are some films that touch on it*). “Feminine” may not be the right word, but “nurturing” certainly is.
*Films include: Chocolat, Mistress of Spices, Babette’s Feast, Eat Drink Man Woman, Like Water for Chocolate, etc. But these are fiction; we are not shown the real very often.