subscribe: Posts | Comments

Why do women prefer calm men?

3 comments

A study conducted by human behavioural ecologists at the University of Abertay Dundee (Scotland) has found that women prefer men with lower cortisol (stress linked hormone) levels, pill contrary to the common belief that testosterone plays a more important role in attractiveness of men.

The study findings are biologically explicable as persistently high levels of cortisol can suppress not just the immune system, look but also reproductive function, online thus making less stressed men better mates, according to the Hindustan Times.

For the study, the researchers recruited 39 young male students and measured their cortisol and testosterone levels, and then had 42 straight female students from a different university rate photos of these men for attractiveness, masculinity and health.

Men with low cortisol levels were often rated as more attractive than guys with high cortisol levels. Testosterone levels were not significantly linked with attractiveness, masculinity or health.

Further, women were found to be more attracted to low cortisol men when in the fertile phase of their menstrual cycle. “We speculate, then, that males with low cortisol possess something desirable that women seek to secure for their offspring. This could be, for example, good health or a healthy response to stress,” said one of the researchers Fhionna Moore.

I would also speculate that women are, in this way, securing their safety by choosing men less likely to be involved in rash incidents of violence against women.

  1. Maria Harvey says:

    I would speculate that: a) This study has far FAR too few subjects in it to give rise to any significant data, and b) That serial domestic abusers are far from being ‘rash’ – their incidents of violence are calculated to maintain their dominance and control of the relationship.

  2. I thoroughly agree with both points made by Maria Harvey.

    It seems superfluous to try and provide some kind of scientific explanation of “why women prefer calm men”, when it’s rather obvious that a stressed and angry partner will cause problems in a relationship and indeed be a source of stress for the woman, and so less preferable. It also seems oblivious to the very real problem of male violence and abuse towards female partners. In short, of course anyone would prefer a calm partner to a stressed partner.

    Also, some women prefer women.

    However, the research doesn’t actually explain anything of the sort. It consisted of showing a set of women pictures of unknown men (not even pictures of real men, just weird aggregate pictures of male faces derived from lots of photos), and asking them to rate their attractiveness, and also rate their perceived “masculinity” and health. It tells us nothing about the women’s real life preferences and actual partner choices, or about the actual calmness or behaviour of the men in the study.

    The research as reported does not demonstrate to us that men with low-cortisol levels are less stressed and behave more calmly than men with high-cortisol levels. Nor does it explain how cortisol levels might affect a man’s facial appearance. Presumably cortisol levels change in response to the presence or absence of things that stress you out – I don’t see how this is perceptible in someone’s face. If I were to interpret whether someone is stressed or calm at any particular time, it would be via their expression, their behaviour, their tone of voice, their words and actions!

    Here is the University of Abertay’s press release about the research:
    http://www.abertay.ac.uk/about/news/newsarchive/2010/name,6448,en.html

    Googling for the research mainly brings up an awful lot of general news stories or popular science/psychology website news stories that basically regurgitate the press release.

    Here is the abstract of the research – the language is rather impenetrable. The gist is, knowing of observed correlation of cortisol levels and attractiveness in some bird species, they predict that a similar correlation might be observed in humans.
    http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/early/2010/09/09/rspb.2010.1678.abstract

    And here is the actual research survey, rating the faces, that you can do online:
    http://psych.abertay.ac.uk/cycle2/pis.html

    I got part way through it, rating the faces for attractiveness, but then it was asking me to rate the faces based on my perception of their “masculinity”, and given that I think gender is a social construct, and that from pictures of faces I cannot make any kind of comparison about their masculinity in the narrowly biological sense, I could not in all honesty give meaningful answers. I think that it would have later asked me to offer a rating based on my perception of their health, and that would have been similarly meaningless.

    I didn’t find any of the faces personally very attractive, and gave most a middling score (the ratings were between 1 and 7). I didn’t find any actively unattractive. Most of the faces were very samey – all white men with young features. I gave one a slightly higher rating simply because he looked distinctly different and was therefore more interesting!

    So, this wasn’t any meaningful measure of how attracted I was to the pictures, because I wasn’t attracted to any of them very much. There are so many other aspects to factor in – talking to someone not least, or their hair and clothing style (you don’t see that at all), how they move, how they treat you. This study can’t say anything definitive about heterosexual women’s preferences, because preferences are highly personal and individual, and the study does not offer enough range to express that fully in the choices on offer.

    At most I was expressing an inkling of interest, and certainly not a sweeping judgement on my perception ot the unreal person in the picture’s reproductive fitness. This is another problem with this kind of research, attributing people’s choices and preferences to some unconscious reproductive strategy. What about lesbian, gay & bisexual people’s partner preferences?

    (Reading about some of these studies, you can’t help feeling that they are overlooking the great advantage one should have in studying humans over studying animals: individual humans can explain and theories about their own behaviour and preferences themselves.)

    Additionally, the study makes authoritative statements linking women’s preferences to the stages in their menstrual cycle. As you will see from the online survey, this seems to be entirely self-reported, so I cannot see how the researchers can conclude as definitively as they do that when women are in their fertile phase their preference is such and such.

    More generally I think we have to ask, what is the purpose of attempting to come to scientific conclusions about partner choices? This kind of research, of which there seems to be an abundance, seems to serve little practical use in terms of furthering people’s wellbeing other than providing reams of news stories that trade on people’s anxieties about relationships and finding a partner. Offering seemingly authorititave (yet impossible to fulfil if you tried them all) answers as to how to be attractive. So the implicit take-home message of this particular research would seem to be that to “get” a woman, straight men should be less stressed.

    It would be interesting to know more about attraction between individuals – we call it “chemistry” because it’s often compelling, physical and not driven by intellectual reasoning – but you can’t realistically aspire to a one-size-fits-all humans general explanation in the way that this study does. I know that I have a few consistent “types” among all the people I’ve ever been attracted to, but there’s so many other non-scientific factors driving if and when and who I actually have relationships or sex with. (I think it would also be best studied alongside other kinds of very individualised preferences and tastes too.)

    • Oh, and with regard to the research survey linked to, another obvious flaw, to my untrained eye anyway, is that it explains to the research participant exactly what they are are researching, e.g. stress hormones, perceived masculinity and so on. Surely this cannot help but influence the way that the participant will approach the task of rating faces? Surely one would get more objective results if the participants simply rated attractiveness and gave information about their menstrual cycles, without knowing what was being researched?

      I still can’t get over the definitive,unproblematic way in which the researchers discuss the concept of “attractiveness”, which is too nebulous and highly individual to be talked of this way.

      Also it is very problematic that they ask participants to rate “masculinity”, as surely cultural and socialised ideas about what gender is and what is gender-appropriate will come into play, and make the results difficult to interpret usefully.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *