Blood groups and fertility: or when good science is badly reported
Across all the major news media this morning are the results of a recent study from the Albert Einstein College of Medicine (AECM in New York) and Yale University, linking women’s blood group to fertility.
The study comprised blood samples taken from 560 women in order to analyze levels of ‘follicle stimulating hormone’ or FSH, a known marker for levels of fertility.
The results showed that women with blood group ‘O’ were more likely to have higher levels of FSH than any other blood group. Higher levels of FSH indicate that a woman may have more difficulty in conceiving than women with lower levels.
Dr Edward Nejat from AECM presented the study’s findings at the American Society for Reproductive Medicine Conference in Denver. This is the first time that fertility levels have been linked to blood group, but Dr Nejat emphasised that FSH levels are just one indicator and that a woman’s age remains the main general indicator for her fertility. He also highlighted that further research was needed.
And that, basically is the whole story.
Not that you would necessarily gain that impression from the press coverage, with this morning’s headlines ranging from:
‘Blood type could bar women from conceiving’ (Sky News)
‘Blood type may be key to fertility’ (The Mirror)
‘Women with type O blood ‘could struggle to get pregnant” (Metro)
Well, as long as we’re not just scaremongering then. There’s something about women’s fertility studies that really draws the media into a kind of sci-fi feeding frenzy.
So before rushing off to get your blood type confirmed or, if you’re a type O, abandoning all hopes of a family, let’s just review the facts.
This is a study of 560 American women out of a global population of 3,361,154,752 (Source: CIA World Factbook).
The study links one indicator of fertility to blood type, the first time any study has attempted to do so, according to the British Fertility Society (as reported in the Guardian, today).
The leading scientist of the study says more research is needed before drawing conclusions.
In reading this story, I confess to being heavily influenced by the book ‘Bad Science’ by Ben Goldacre, which is my current bedtime reading (yes, I know you don’t have to be a scientist to make the link between this admission and the reason why I’m single).
In his book, Ben argues powerfully and with humour that the lack of accurate scientific reporting in the mainstream media results in lazy, sloppy coverage of scientific research based on headline-hunting hacks who are more interested in sales than science.
Admittedly, some of the press have attempted to tread carefully in representing this story, for instance with mindful use of words like ‘can’, ‘could’ and ‘may’ in drawing the links.
But this study could just as easily have been reported from the angle of ‘Scientists search for link between blood type and fertility’ – a story that in its telling would have revealed far more about the existing body of work in the field of reproductive science, the reasons for searching for such a link in the first place and the benefits of the study to future scientific work in reproductive health and technology.
Instead we have another potential scare story about women’s struggle to conceive.
















Would just like to say that I read ‘bad science’ on my anniversary holiday with my dear man and somehow we stayed together. I therefore reject your hypothesis that there is a link between the book and singleness. Also, statistically speaking. you are unlikely to stay single.
I agree with you about bad science and scaremongering. All hail Ben, and I think my O type blood will do me as well as it did my mother who managed to procreate just fine.
Thanks Scanner – I stand corrected. Having said that, I do enjoy being single and am quite reluctant to give it up, so although you’re right about my single status not being linked to the book, statistically I’m entirely likely to stay single if I continue to refuse to have a relationship…..!! 🙂