False memory syndrome raises its ugly head again
Meredith Maran has just had a book published detailing how she falsely accused her father of molesting her as a child.
‘When I was a little girl, my dad and I had everything in common, including this: we liked each other more than either of us liked my mother. When I was in my 30s, I accused my father of molesting me. I didn’t see him or talk to him for eight years. I didn’t let my children see him, either. And then I realised that it wasn’t true.’
The implications of the book are that because a ‘handful of feminist scholars’ in the 1970s asserted that incest wasn’t a rare anomaly and repressed memory had allowed this to be unacknowledged, a wave of therapists got caught up in these findings are started to implant ‘false memories’ in their clients’ memories. This then resulted in these clients falsely accusing their fathers/uncles/adult males in their lives, causing families to be torn apart.
Whilst I accept that some women may have misremembered their past, there are two things that disturb me about this story.
Firstly this comment by Maran’s mother when asked by Maran about the abuse: “When you were two years old,” she said shakily, “he told me you looked too sexy in your bathing suit. He was so angry. His reaction sickened me. I didn’t know why.” Sexy in a bathing suit at 2 years old? What?
The second thing – as with the ‘she falsely cried rape’ defence being used to try and dismiss the number of sexual assaults that women routinely suffer – is that if she did falsely accuse her father, that is a tragedy, but this should not be used to negate the stories of thousands of child abuse survivors who remember very well what happened to them.
Read the full story in the Guardian.











