subscribe: Posts | Comments

Wired, breasts, interns and the sexualization of science

9 comments

Since the publication of this story on Monday 25th October, the accuracy, or rather inaccuracy of the original story posted here has been rightfully brought to our attention by a number of our readers – you can read their input for yourself at the bottom of the page in the comments section.

It had been my original intention to retain the original story, including its inaccuracies, with an additional follow-up at the bottom of the page aimed at correcting the elements of the story that were later discovered to be wrong.

However, a number of our readers feel very strongly that this does not go far enough, so I have corrected the story in its entirety, and rewritten the post, as requested by several readers, to remove the inaccuracies entirely.

While I have to confess a rewrite does not sit well with me in terms of feeling as though I am ‘covering up’ mistakes that I believe should be kept transparent, I respect the views of the readers who have posted here that to retain the original mistakes in the story may perpetuate the inaccuracies further.

As such, I agree with our readers and have removed the inaccurate statements altogether; the full story is represented on the blog of Shelby Knox for interested readers to follow.

I would like to apologise to the staff at Wired for any offence caused by the original story and am happy to fully retract the mistakes made.

I would like to confirm that the staff who appeared in the photograph referred to at the Wired Tumblr blog did so at their own behest to represent their views and support for the magazine as they saw fit, and to confirm that those staff were not interns, as originally stated.

I would also like to thank our readers for following the story closely, and for continuing to contact us to express their views on our coverage.

As WVON is run entirely by volunteers, we are heavily dependent on our readers to assist us in following up stories and particularly, as in this case, helping us to correct inaccuracies. We could not do it without you, thank you.

Finally, I would like to state that all inaccuracies and mistakes were entirely my own work, and I retain full responsibility for them.

Following the decision by Wired Magazine to promote a recent cover story on the use of tissue regeneration in helping breast cancer survivors by plastering their cover with an image of naked breasts, the feminist blogosphere has been quick to highlight why such an approach may not be helpful.

If this story has passed you by, I invite you first of all to visit Wired and read for yourself an excellent piece of scientific journalism by writer Sharon Begley entitled All Natural: Why breasts are the key to the future of regenerative medicine.

I think it’s vital to read the article so that you can honestly ask yourself it is was necessary for the magazine team to market the story in the way that they chose. I think not, but no real surprises there.

Once you’ve read the article for yourself, head over to Shelby Knox’s blog, who has written a great opinion piece about why the marketing of this story in Wired really turned her off.

As you may already know, I repeated some of Shelby’s article in my original post here, some of the details of which were inaccurate. Although I have amended this article in response, Shelby has retained her original article at the link above, and posted an updated answer, apology and restatement of her opinion on the marketing of the story at Shelby’s blog.

I think it is well worth paying a visit to both articles, not only to hear all sides of this very interesting story within a story, but also because I think Shelby Knox deals with the mistakes in her original reporting with great integrity.

She also does not shift from her original viewpoint, which is that the sexualisation of the marketing of Sharon Begley’s story was unnecessary, and somewhat sad. I am inclined, with Shelby, to continue to share that view.

And Shelby wasn’t the only one to feel that way.

Over at the Discover magazine blog, Sheril Kershinbaum shows the cover itself in situ on a shop magazine stall, and expresses her disappointment that Wired chose to promote the story in this way, especially in a context where science magazines seem to be marketed more at men than women.

“A wonderful magazine full of terrific articles that looks a lot like ‘Hooters’ on the cover will not encourage a lot of women to make it to the articles. They are choosing their audience, which is their decision, but when it comes to STEM, I’d like to see more influential S&T publications reaching out to  appeal to more of a female audience, too,” writes Sheril.

Interestingly, senior editor of Wired, Adam Rogers takes the time to respond to Sheril’s criticisms, stating that “we chose a cover to be provocative. That’s in our job description. Got lucky in that a subject that famously sells magazines also, in this case, happens to be a brilliant science article.”

You can read more responses from readers, including Sheril herself, at the post page linked to above.

And we’d also love to hear your thoughts on this one.

Was the cover used for the story appropriate? Is it justifiable to use a salacious image to raise awareness on important scientific developments?

Or is it all simply a storm in a D cup? (Ok, that last one was almost unforgivable, but it has been a long day.)

  1. PleaseUpdate says:

    Shelby Knox has retracted her blog due to, it turns out, terrible misstatements that defamed and hurt the male staffers it implicated, and the female staffers it dismissed as manipulated stooges: http://shelbyknox.com/2010/10/25/update-women-of-wired-respond/

    Please amend this post -which continues to perpetuate the false rumor that female “interns” were coerced in any way – to reflect the more sober reality.

    As the Women of Wired write:

    I understand your frustration. Wired Yourself was conceptualized, produced, and maintained by we, the women posted in its inaugural pictures. Not our bosses. And certainly not by coercion, prompting, or suggestion. To assume so would miss the perhaps-too-subtle-for-the-internet-when-boobs-are-involved point. Also, it hurt our feelings a little. Our intent was to stand behind (literally) the magazine cover by reclaiming the anonymous image as our own, in celebration of the idea that she is all women and we are all her. The breasts on Wired are emblems of an era when post-masectomy reconstruction won’t mean the choice between an artificial implant and scar tissue. So, read the article, and learn about the amazing, liberating future for breast cancer survivors. If you’re like us, it’ll make you want to stand up and cheer.

    -The ladies of WiredYourself, acting, as always, on their own volition.

  2. Accuracy says:

    If you had thoroughly read the update to Shelby Knox’s blog post, you would have seen that not only did she apologize for making false statements (which you have just repeated as truths), but also that the management at Wired had nothing to do with the taking of the photos or their posting (and the tumblr in question was created by the women in the photo). Please try to refrain from perpetuating these rumors.

  3. The now-extinct website referred to in the first paragraph of the entry above had absolutely no official connection to Wired magazine or any Wired staffers beyond those in the photo. None whatsoever. That was a mistake made by Ms. Knox in her initial post, which was then corrected in a follow-up post on her website and accompanied by an apology for doing so. But not before everyone had a chance to pick up the pitchfork and charge, apparently. No marketing was involved. No strategy was involved. No machinations on behalf of the senior editors were involved. I know all of this because I was in the photo. This was not a viral campaign. It was a lark. The “approach” critiqued by the blogosphere never existed, which makes all subsequent commentary about it baseless and void. The only story here is the story itself by Sharon Begley, and it’s a damn fine one.

  4. Accuracy says:

    From Shelby Knox’s blog:
    ****This piece has been updated following a response by the women of Wired Magazine. Please click here (http://shelbyknox.com/2010/10/25/update-women-of-wired-respond) to see the new piece, which corrects misinformation stated below. I chose not to delete this post entirely because I believe it is responsible blogging practice to keep my f**ck ups where people can find them instead of pretending they never happened. It holds me accountable and maintains a public history of an event for people looking to reflect back on it in the future. Please cease any harassment of Wired staff, as I am the only one deserving of blame in this situation.****

  5. Thanks to all who have commented here on this one and for the updates on the story. I think Shelby’s additional post speaks for itself and I’ll amend the article post above to include that link so that readers can follow the entire story from start to finish.

    There’s a lesson here too about fact checking for online writers, myself included, so thank you to our readers for your help on that. Nonetheless, I think the decision to raise comment and question on the Wired decision on their front cover is still a valid one, not only on Shelby’s part but also on the part of Sheril Kirshenbaum and the readers on both of their sites who express agreement.

    Cheers,

    Sarah

  6. PleaseUpdate says:

    That your “Follow Up” is at the bottom and the post remains in its original, un-amended, uncorrected for is just-this-side of reckless.

    Please your readership, the women implicated by the rumor you continue to perpetuate, and the integrity of Women’s Views on News. Please, amend the post. A separate PS without any treatment in the article itself is not a correction, and this piece continues to spread throughout the headline-catching internet.

    Please make responsible changes TO THE ARTICLE and end the sad perpetuation of potentially career-ending (for the women in the pictures) false accusations.

  7. PleaseUpdate says:

    The women are not *interns*. An odd assumption to make. Young women at a major magazine must occupy the lowest rung on institutional ranks? For goodness sakes!

    Also, the staffers you implicate were not “allowed” to pose on “their” website. These women made their own tumblr – independent of Wired Magazine. You’re creating a fiction to make your point, Sarah. This is as unfortunately irresponsible as it is damaging.

    Please do the right thing and de-sensationalize this bizarre post.

  8. ForShame says:

    This is as unfortunately irresponsible as it is damaging.

    Please do the right thing and de-sensationalize this bizarre post. You call the staffers interns? You claim it’s Wired-sponsored? As a feminist, as a reader, I find this sloppy at best, poisonous at worst.

    How can this sill be up?

  9. concerned writer says:

    Sarah,

    I found this while trying to piece together my reaction to the Wired cover.

    It’s saddening to see this piece’s lies, conjecture, falsities, wild accusations, mis-attributions, and downright libelous hand waving STILL on your website. A sad day for cogency. That you keep this up, that the first paragraphs remain uncorrected (come on – we know it’s after the first three paragraphs that people start to skim) makes it hard for the rest of us to be taken seriously. Not to mention the women you call “interns” when they’ve certainly worked hard to move past that low-level stage.

    Fix it. Make it right in every sense of the word.

    – Ellen A.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *