subscribe: Posts | Comments

Jong claims attachment parenting imprisons women

3 comments

Erica Jong always has known how to provoke reaction and debate and her article in the Wall Street Journal criticising attachment parenting has really stirred things up.

In today’s New York Times there is a response to Jong’s assertion that attachment parenting has imprisoned mothers by Katie Allison Granju.

Katie writes that she chooses to sleep with her baby, not because she feels she must but because after a day at work she likes to spend this time with her infant. She also rounds on Jong’s suggestion that attachment parenting has played into the hands of the right because it leaves no time for women to think and demonstrate.

It’s an interesting debate between the two women of different generations and who look at feminism from different perspectives.

  1. This is an interesting subject – as a mother approaching 50 with a 21 year old son, the idea of attachment parenting is an anathema. But maybe my generation were closer to the (very recent) freedoms fought for by feminists of the previous generation. And therefore we valued our own freedom from what we saw as the tyranny of wifedom and childcare. It will be interesting to see if this generation of mothers and children fare any better than we did.

    • Thanks for your comment. I’m still trying to work out my stance, as I identified with Katie while at the same time know that I am benefitting from all the freedoms won by second wave feminists. Perhaps because I have this freedom of choice, I can choose to be ‘attached’ without feeling it is a tyranny?

      • Yes indeed Jackie – you have probably hit the nail on the head. Perhaps the real freedom that both first and second wave feminism gave us was the freedom to enter into a dialogue about what it is to be a woman.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *