Justice for all? Or just for the police?
Mustaf Jama, one of six men convicted in connection with the death of police officer Sharon Beshenivsky, is launching an appeal on the fifth anniversary of her death.
PC Beshenivsky had been a police officer for only nine months when she was killed in 2005, and was survived by a husband and five children and step-children. She was killed, and her colleague wounded, during a bungled robbery at a London travel-agency.
Mustafa Jama fled to Somalia within days of the robbery and was returned to the UK in 2007, following what the Yorkshire Post describe as ‘a daring mission’ in the Somali desert- the costs of which were split across the Home Office, Foreign Office and West Yorkshire Police.
Although Mustafa Jama did not fire the fatal shot, the prosecution at his trial contended he was “as much guilty of murder” as the gunman. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a 35 year minimum term.
In another story reported by WVON today, a police officer has been dismissed but not charged for committing an act of ‘non-consensual’ sex, known to the rest of us as rape.
Despite an investigation by the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) that found the officer guilty of committing what its Commissioner described as a ‘predatory’ and exploitative act against a ‘vulnerable young woman’, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has seen fit not to press charges against the same officer – so he loses his job but not his liberty.
IPCC Commissioner Rachel Cerfontyne described the rape survivor as showing “tremendous bravery…first to report the incident…then to carry on even when she had been told the man was a police officer.”
I think the actions of the police authorities in both of these cases is noteworthy and commendable. The commitment to seeing justice done in the case of the tragic death of PC Beshenivsky is highly admirable and I’m glad that all the people involved in her attack were found.
That the IPCC have seen fit to fire this man even though the CPS has let her down so very badly may go some way, as Commissioner Cerfontyne hopes “will restore some of the victim’s faith in the police.”
I hope so too, because she – along with many other women in the country – almost certainly won’t have any faith in the British justice system. Why did the CPS turn the case down anyway?
No information is included in the IPCC press release, leaving me with the terrible fear that the involvement of alcohol in the case is enough to warrant denying a jury the opportunity of making up their own mind.
The dedication of the government and justice system in ensuring – rightly – that the perpetrators of PC Sharon Beshenivsky were brought to justice stands in stark contrast to the failure to ensure justice is done in the case of the young woman attacked by the police officer.
There should be no such disparity in our pursuit of justice as a society. Whether they are the victims or the perpetrators of crime, it is vital that cases involving police officers – just like anyone else – are pursued with equal levels of dedication and persistence.
Read the full reports at the BBC, the Yorkshire Post and the IPCC.











