Why should mums stay at home?
“Children do better in school if their mother stays home for the first year”. This may be true – but the truth can be misleading.
The Daily Mail today published its summary of a research study conducted by Macalester College, Minnesota, and the University of California.
The research was a meta-analysis – a study of previous studies – designed to aggregate enough data to provide some sort of empirical average about the impact of working mothers on child achievement.
But the whether or not the mother worked was only one amongst a whole host of variables including class, income and whether children were parented singly or jointly.
In some circumstances children did fare marginally better if their mothers stayed at home for the first year after the birth. But this is where the Daily Mail’s headline ‘truth’ ends.
For working class mothers and single parents, the financial benefits achieved by returning to work far outweighed the loss of the mother’s presence.
Research in the nineteenth century achieved similar results when female factory workers were found to have healthier infants because they themselves could afford to eat properly.
Importantly, the Macalester analysis of 69 separate studies carried out worldwide since 1960 concluded that overall, across all social classes, a mother returning to work within the first three years did not lead to reduced achievement at school or behavioural problems.
Why then has the Daily Mail presented the study in this way?
In the 1940s psychologist John Bowlby conducted research into mother / infant separation. His work focused on the role of infant attachment. Later, Bowlby’s research was supported by research into the behaviour of infant monkeys raised in isolation and without a mother. Instead, the infant primates had access to nourishment but their only access to maternal comfort was a cloth covered wire-mesh to which they could cling.
Unsurprisingly, the infants grew up into unstable emotionally scarred adults that had few, if any, parenting skills. A lack of attachment between infant and mother was seen as the cause and described in terms of maternal deprivation.
Bowlby’s research was conducted at a time when both British and US governments were facing employment problems that arose form their role in the total war of WW2.
Both nations had enlisted large numbers of female workers into the labour force in order to replace male workers that were drafted into the armed forces. Women were present in the labour force in higher numbers than ever before and significantly, they were employed in traditionally male roles.
As the menfolk were de-mobbed, women were to be gently ushered back into their former roles in order than the returning men could return to their pre-war employment.
The need to have women return to the home had, however, been anticipated and throughout the war propaganda posters in factories and workshops reminded women that they were only helping out while the men were at war. Once the men were back, women could return to their former roles and give up their work for men.
The freedom that women gained as a consequence of war time employment was not to be surrendered so easily and although many women were happy to return to home and kitchen, many women wanted to remain in the workplace.
It was against this background that Bowlby conducted his work. Unsurprisingly, his research findings were used to support the claim that children were better off if their mothers remained at home to raise and care for them.
Juvenile delinquency and maternal neglect were constructed as two sides of the same coin and women were cast as being responsible. Maternal neglect and the selfishness of the career mother emerged as a cause of social dysfunction.
Women then, for the sake of their children’s welfare, should return to their primary of role carer and mother.
Maternal culpability was not new, indeed, the idea had been used throughout the nineteenth and twentieth centuries as a means of prescribing female behaviour. All that was new after WW2 was the cause to which it was put.
My point? – Don’t be distracted by the Daily Mail’s headline. Instead take it as an indicator of a broader social trend and look beyond it to the socio-economic context in which it was produced.
We are currently experiencing a period of economic hardship. Cut backs in the public sector will mean that women will suffer disproportionately with large numbers of part-time and low paid women losing their jobs.
Women’s role as the reserve labour pool means that female unemployment is not taken as seriously as male unemployment. It is also easier to appease. And, if women leave the labour market then competition for jobs is reduced.
If it is not children who gain directly from women staying at home then who does gain and who loses out?
Oh – and the children that are disadvantaged by their mothers working – the children of middle class two parent families that do not live in poverty. In other words, if there are two parents in a family and enough money to live on and your mother goes back to work then you may achieve slightly less well in school but only in comparison to other children living in the same circumstances. But you achievement will still be higher than that of children who live in poverty.
















Whenever I point out the real intention of Bowlby’s research to my students, they are quite rightly shocked and outraged. As they should be.
OOPS. Pressed submit too soon.
There seems every reason to believe now that the Mail has the same agenda as Bowlby, and is keen of forcing women back into the home. It won’t, of course, get away with it.