Everyone is a human being – of students, demos, police, and South Africa
PhD student blogger Anna Hedge has some inspiring recommendations for addressing the violent clashes during demonstrations over tuition fees, over at her blog, Langtry Girl.
Following on from our earlier coverage of Laurie Penny’s New Statesman blog detailing the violent clashes at Thursday’s demo, Anna urges us to follow the example of South Africa in negotiating peaceful demonstrations.
Her recommendations come, she writes, from the South African Independent Electoral Commission’s handbook on protest management and the need for cooperation between police and protesters.
“The starting point was: Everyone is a human being. Simple…It is impossible to manage (as opposed to oppress) a large group of people if their humanity has been forgotten.”
Her post contains a number of practical solutions, including:
- accountable leadership for demonstrators
- more, experienced stewards working to an agreed, structured framework
- meetings between student and police leaders before demos, not only with the aim of preparing for the demonstration but also of building tangible, active relationships between police and protest movement
- banning metal barriers from being used by the police
- the commitment to stop the policy of ‘kettling’ or containment used by the police this week.
I agree with the practical suggestions Anna suggests, but most of all, I agree with her overall philosophy in approaching demos.
“But..What if there’s a riot?” she writes, “What if a steward lies, or a policeman? Are we really supposed to let brick-chucking fifteen year olds go home to Mummy? Should we trust the police? Anarchists?….students? Hangers on?
“Yes. We don’t, but we should do all those things. After all, we are all human, remember?”
Recommended reading.











