Burlesque – sexuality subverted or just a different packet?
There was a very interesting conversation about burlesque on Woman’s Hour this morning.
The discussion between burlesque star Ophelia Bitz and London Feminist Network member Dr Julia Long was chaired by presenter Jane Garvey (who seemed to be quite uncomfortable for the duration of the conversation).
All the people involved consider themselves to be feminist and all recognised that we live in a hypersexual society.
You can probably imagine how the rest of the discussion went.
Long asserted that burlesque is an enactment of tired and outdated sexism.
The root of the word ‘burlesque’ is from the Spanish for ‘joke’, it is a comedic artform, the focus of which, Long argued, is the teasing female object at the centre of a subjective male gaze.
Bitz defended burlesque by saying that stripping is not at it’s heart, it is an aesthetic art and you are more likely to find the audiences are predominantly female.
There are several things that I can never quite make my mind up about. Burlesque is one of them. I simultaneously like and hate the idea of it.
My favourite magazine, Alan Moore’s Dodgem Logic, loves burlesque.
Dodgem Logic is Northampton’s underground socialist, feminist, reflective, critical, anarchistic, imaginative and brilliant publication and issue 2 brought a choice of 3 covers, all showing big, beautiful burlesque stars and I wasn’t quite sure what to make of it.
The article on burlesque inside states that it is an empowering form of entertainment. It gives you the freedom to express your sexuality. This same opinion was shared by Ophelia Bitz on Woman’s Hour this morning.
Burlesque is considered to be ‘alternative’. Women who perform have varied body types, the ‘tease’ is certainly much darker than straightforward stripping, or pole-dancing and it refuses to play up to the skinny homogenisation of desire you find in mainstream magazines and on the high street.
However, there is very much a class distinction here. The women who take part in burlesque, which is often described as ‘posh stripping’, tend to be from a better socio-economic background than high street strippers and earn much more from their performances because they are considered to be ‘artists’ as opposed to ‘strippers’.
We don’t have to look far to see that what is ‘sexy’ is often prescribed rather than expressed, whether mainstream or underground.
In Laurie Penny’s recent article on the ‘Erotica’ event which took place in London a couple of weeks ago, she criticises what she considers to be a capitalisation of desire. Everything we want is in a plastic package, ready and waiting for us to buy into it.
Burlesque, with its stockings and corsets, is no different therefore, than any other desire you can peruse and purchase.
Whenever I’m faced with my own confusion on matters such as burlesque I go back to Crimethinc‘s piece on the vanguard of the sexual revolution, which I agree with completely. It argues that sex is rarely honest and so rarely beautiful because when people sleep together they meet as roles played rather than individuals.
However much burlesque dancers such as Ophelia Bitz maintain that fringe shows are emboldening and edgy, I cannot help but think that it is just another performance and does little for honest sexuality.
Listen to the full interview here (from about 10 minutes in until about 20 minutes in)











