subscribe: Posts | Comments

Family slams report into mother’s murder

5 comments

The family of a woman murdered by her ex-boyfriend has severely criticised a report into the police handling of the case.

Marie Stubbing, 50, was killed in her home in Chelmsford, Essex, less than a year after Marc Chivers had been released from a German prison for killing another ex-girlfriend.

Her daughter said that the police already knew of his background when Mrs Stubbing made a complaint of sexual assault by Chivers.

Sky News reports that her family are unhappy about a report in the case which they say amounts to a ‘ticking off’ for officers involved.

Her brother Manuel Fernandez said: “I am presented with a report which fails to recognise fully the countless errors the police made – it is scant in detail to say the least.

“I question the time the investigation took, and the capabilities of those conducting it, not to mention the cost to the public purse, for a report which is weak and vague.”

  1. Jane Osmond says:

    I saw a report on this on the BBC news this morning – the daughter was distraught, and quite rightly so. We keep hearing that the police are not adequately trained to spot potential murderers of this type, just as we keeping hearing that they are not adequately trained to deal with rape victims properly. When are the police going to be trained properly to deal with violence against women? it is just not good enough to dismiss women when they tell the police that they are in danger from an ex – do the police think they are making it up? Or is it that the police do not feel the same kind of fear as the ordinary public so they dismiss the level of threat? In any event, in this case the guy had already been convicted for killing a previous girlfriend – how could they possibly not take that seriously? This makes me furious – as long as the police keep dismissing women and letting them be murdered, the men who commit these crimes can just carry on with impunity. My heart goes out to Ms Stubbing’s daughter – she was so angry this morning and I am as well.

  2. vicki wharton says:

    I went through an incident of domestic violence last year – when the police arrived the male officer that questioned my partner (who has since been through a domestic violence councilling programme that has changed his behaviour immeasurably) rounded on me and read me the riot act for fighting in front of our daughter. When I took him through the various items of physical evidence that backed me in up in my assertion that I was actually defending myself and not the aggressor – the police officer backed down, but it was a hard job to persuade him using the evidence not to arrest me such was his level of bigotry. 3 months later I went to the police station to file a complaint against him as the police would not take my complaint by phone and sat for 4 hours in the police station whilst they told me people were too busy to take my complaint. When I complained to the IPCC some months later they told me that as a year had just passed since the incident itself in which I had not complained, they were deeming it closed as there is a year cutoff point for dealing with police complaints. When I pointed out that I had tried to complain twice – by phone and in person and they had not taken down my complaint – the police came back saying as there was no evidence of me complaining and no one remembered me being there and the paperwork had gone missing as to who the officer was anyway – there was no case to answer. Some people call it incompetence, some others might call it lying.

    • Thanks for your comment. It is clear from what you say that the police have much work to do to improve their response to domestic violence. It takes much courage to call the police in the first place, and then if the victim is not supported when officers arrive – or in the weeks after – it obviously leaves them even more vulnerable, as the perpetrator believes they can get away with it. Also it’s harder for the victim to move on psychologically if they feel they have not been treated justly. Cases like yours highlight the need for urgent changes.

      • vicki wharton says:

        My partner took a courageous step in confronting his aggression towards me – Im not sure police men are fit to police other men’s violence – they become partisan and empathise with the aggressor, not the victim whom they see as responsible for her own assault through living the life of an equal rather than subordinate being … this in fact holds true pretty much of nearly all men and most women who side with the dominant caste in an effort to keep out of harm’s way themselves or perhaps they like bullying too!?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *