subscribe: Posts | Comments

Re-thinking pink this christmas

4 comments

Some good news today too. Campaign group Pink Stinks report that the gender stereotypes that have dominated the children’s market for years now, may be starting to face a backlash, according to an article in the Guardian.

After a prolongued protest against girl/boy segregation at the Early Learning Centre, Pink Stinks are cautiously suggesting that the lurid pink tide may have turned.

And its not just the Early Learning Centre either. Disney are poised to pull the plug on their princess production line, signalling the end, perhaps, of tiaras, and frills, and acres of neon pink fabric designed purely for little girls.

Abi Moore, co-founder of Pink Stinks, says her organisation has been inundated with messages from parents all over the world.

“Our campaign last year was covered in 43 countries. We are constantly being asked by parents, ‘What can we do?'” Parents of girls and boys alike are sick of the marketing messages and, especially, the gender assumptions children are forced to lap up.”

So is this an example of feminist parenting in action, or merely a blip in the overall trend? Read the full article and make your own mind up.

  1. Great picture! Reminds me of the Shrek princesses’ fight scene!

  2. Does anyone watch the One Show on BBC One? I don’t normally catch it but happened to see it tonight.

    I was absolutely appauled by their ‘toys wars’ segments that pitted ‘boys toys’ against ‘girls toys’. The boys were presenting their favourite toys – lightsabers, remote control cars, transformers etc… all good fun, action stuff. The girls presented a series of dolls (Barbie, Brats, JLS) and toy dogs that pretend to pee. God give me strength.

    So the usual story – boys are the action heroes, girls are the carers.

    I had to put my dinner down and phone a complaint through (03700 100 222). I would expect this rubbish on ITV but on BBC One?! This is 2010… right?! Jeez…

  3. I agree about the picture, good find!

    I’m not so convinced that the re-think is actually happening, although it’s entirely possible that it’s just taking a bit longer (as usual) to reach my Midlands backwater town. I’m a Christmas temp at a bookshop chain and the incredibly gender normative children’s section is really depressing (am I allowed to say the shop name? I’m never sure whether that might end up getting me into trouble? anyway, you’ll all know which one it is.)

    All the girls’ stuff is pink and about things like pop stars, princesses and shopping, while the boys’ stuff is about fun and almost educational stuff like astronauts, pirates and dinosaurs. Boys have ‘The Boys’ Book of Survival’, girls have ‘The Girls’ Book of Glamour’. A title I saw yesterday was called ‘What Does Daddy Do?’, as if no child would need to ask what Mummy does because Mummy is meant to be looking after the children.

    Just because Disney is moving away from princesses, doesn’t mean other companies aren’t lying in the wings ready to pick up the slack, and although ELC’s decision is to be congratulated, getting rid of gender segregation doesn’t mean it’s not still painfully obvious which toys are intended for which gender – my bookshop is testament to that. Sorry to be such a sceptic! ELC is definitely doing some good work here and hopefully all the positive comments from feminists on the internet will encourage them, as well as showing other companies that this is the way to go.

    Even though I’m being a bit negative here about the products still being sold in shops, there does seem to be more interest in gender neutral parenting among normal people – by which I mean it’s not only on feminist websites now that you read people worrying about imposing gender norms on their children. Places like mumsnet seem to discuss this too, and this is really encouraging, even though, as I say, it’s not yet reached my town.

  4. vicki wharton says:

    I complained to the BBC about their constant gender warring – there are constant references throughout CBBC and mainstream programmes like Gavin’s Extraordinary School for Boys where the boys are exhorted to do better than the girls – as if doing worse than a girl is the ultimate humiliation for the ‘superior’ sex. It’s all done in an ironic way – typical lads mag positioning – but if you encountered a show that pitched black people against white with the whites being told that they can’t be beat by a black person – I think audiences would be appalled – ironic or not ironic. And we wonder why girls have such poor self esteem – they are just reflecting back the value they are given by society today. Needless to say, the BBC said that unless I could give them the exact time within the programme of each remark – which I couldn’t as I didn’t watch it preprepared to note the exact time of offensive remarks – then they were unable to investigate – I guess they don’t have any playback facilities at their offices …?!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *