Women’s charity lose right to challenge Government
By Heather Kennedy
WVoN co-editor
As WVoN reported yesterday, pill the Fawcett Society has been denied the opportunity to challenge the legality of the Coalition’s emergency budget.
The budget has been met with a plethora of rebukes on the grounds of inequality since it was announced in June. Perhaps the most significant of these was from the Fawcett Society which has a long history of campaigning for equal rights for women.
They were applying for permission to seek a declaration that the Government had acted unlawfully when devising the budget by failing to pay “due regard to gender equality laws”. This is believed to have been the first ever legal challenge to a Government’s budget in the UK.
Pointing to cuts in employment, order benefits and services, Karen Monaghan QC – acting on behalf of the charity – accused the budget of placing a “disproportionate” and “devastating” burden on women. The charity argues that spending cuts risk “rolling back women’s equality in the UK by a generation”.
Under the 1975 Sex Discrimination Act the Government has a duty “to eliminate unlawful discrimination” and actively promote equality of opportunity between men and women.
The hearing did successfully lead to the Government’s admission that budgetary decisions were subject to equality law.
Equality impact assessments (the legal requirement that Government’s measure the impact of their policies) had not be carried out with the necessary rigour they agreed. A Government spokesperson described their failure to carry out gender impact assessments for public sector pay freezes and certain benefit charges as “regrettable”.
Ceri Goddard, Chief Executive of the Fawcett Society, said “although hundreds of thousands of women’s incomes will be affected by the public sector pay freeze, and the poorest pensioners and lone mothers will lose out through the changes to benefits and pensions, the government conceded it had not considered the impact on women and men when drawing up its plans.”
Equality charities have joined the Fawcett Society in arguing that equality impact assessments must also be made public to ensure transparency. There has been widespread concern that assessments don’t become superficial box ticking exercises.
Conducting research into the impact of the Coalition’s budget, the Fawcett Society found that 72% of the money raised by cuts was to be carried by women, against 28% for men.
Research from the House of Commons library matched this; they claimed that of the £8bn to be raised in a single fiscal year, almost £6bn would come from women and only £2bn from men.
The Fawcett Society weren’t disheartened by yesterday’s ruling. Goddard says, since their campaign, “there is increased recognition and understanding of the role of equality law generally, and growing demand that women are not forced to bear the brunt of cuts.
“The issue of women’s rights has inched that little bit closer to its rightful place at the heart of policy making.”
The judge admitted that proceedings could have had “a very significant impact” on the budget but said the Fawcett Society had delayed making their application for too long. He ruled that the application was “unarguable” and legal intervention through the courts would be “academic”.
The Fawcett Society is unlikely to be deterred by yesterday’s ruling. They say that this hearing was part of a much wider campaign for women’s economic independence.
Goddard believes there are plenty of reasons to be positive; “when drawing up the Comprehensive Spending Review, the government produced the first ever equalities statement to accompany such a big piece of financial policy. Though we feel it’s inadequate, it’s a start.”











