subscribe: Posts | Comments

Contraceptive implant concern another ‘pill scare’

1 comment

A GP expert says recent concerns over the contraceptive implant Implanon are unfounded and could undermine years of work to reduce numbers of unplanned pregnancies in primary care.

In a letter sent to the health professional magazine Pulse, Dr Anne Connolly, president of the Primary Care Women’s Health Forum, says recent media reports regarding Implanon were ‘irresponsible.’ 

Moreover, she argues that they will lead to unfounded mistrust of long-acting reversible contraceptions (LARCs) among women.

LARCs have been in the firing line this week, following a documentary by Channel 4 warning of the risk of scarring and that the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency had received reports of 584 unplanned pregnancies in women who had the device fitted.

Dr Connolly said this number was ‘astounding’ considering the 1.3m Implanon devices fitted in the UK since 1999.

She believes that it is one of the ‘most reliable methods [of contraception] currently available in the UK.

‘Encouraging women to use and to be able to easily access reliable “fit and forget” methods like the implant, rather than the easy to forget daily pill-taking regimens, reduces contraception failures.’

Dr Connolly explains that many of the problems were caused by improper insertion of the device, but stresses that this will be addressed with the introduction of a new, ‘relatively fool proof’ version. She adds:

‘Those of us who were working in women’s health in 1995 remember the increased termination of pregnancy rates following the “pill scare” when many women abandoned their oral contraceptive because of the sensational news reports …

‘Many women will now mistrust their method of contraception or refuse to opt for this as their chosen method.’

These remarks come in the wake of much controversy over Implanon, resulting in new guidelines for GPs being introduced. Read WVoN’s previous articles.

  1. I consider myself a committed feminist and wholly support the right of women to control their own biological functioning – and to take whatever risks with their own health they may choose. However, I do not, for one second, believe that the commercially driven motives of the pharmaceutical companies who produce these contraceptives have womens’ welfare anywhere near the top of their priority list. There have been serious side-effects associated with contraceptives before, moreover as in the present case, following confident claims that there was no danger and that everything was perfectly safe. Add into the mix the proclivity of some of these ‘reputable’ companies for using (often unsuspecting) women in poor countries as guinea pigs for trialing their products and nothing would ever induce me to inject/implant/consume anything like this. A friend is currently distraught because of the side-effects her daughter has suffered from a contraceptive implant. Asking intelligent questions about these products and being very cautious is exactly what is needed, imo. There is nothing ‘scare-mongering’ about it – an insult closely related to the sexist ‘hysterical’ term that is all to easily thrown at women over issues like this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *