New Labour responses to violence against women – end of term report
Taken from the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies 31.01.11
In a report by the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies published today, Anette Ballinger (criminology lecturer at Keele University), reviews the ways in which New Labour tried to tackle violence against women.
The publication, entitled ‘Lessons for the coalition’ is a collection of essays on the challenges facing the UK coalition government with regard to the criminal justice system.
Ballinger argues that although much of what Labour did was well intended, the philosophy underpinning their initiatives supported rather than challenged normative, patriarchal social structures.
She points out that New Labour’s pro-arrest and pro-prosecution ‘crime control’ stance was used to siphon money into CCTV, public awareness campaigns and police initiatives.
None of them were shown to work and all of them failed to address unequal power structures that normalise violence against women.
Their rhetorical rather than financial support of refuges and other women’s services ensured that effective responses to domestic violence were marginalised.
This says nothing of the disservice their political prioritising has done for immigrant families who are victims of violence. (The no recourse to public funds campaign is ongoing.)
The other major mistake of the New Labour government was to neutralise gender power relations in the 2003 Sexual Offences Act.
By noting that both men and women can be both perpetrators and victims of violence, Labour removed a key tool useful for both analysis and understanding. Violence against women, as a term, was neutralised.
Masculinity and male power as the source of gendered violence went unchallenged under New Labour, and will continue to be unconfronted by the coalition.
The recent boost of funds to rape crisis centres needs to be just the start of a campaign for mainstream recognition of the brutal effects of patriarchy.
We must hold governments worldwide to account. It is only when wider social structures of violence against women are taken into account that we will be able to start pushing for significant change to properly address gendered violence.
















Very good report on the gendered nature of violence in the home and Labour’s lack of recognition of this point in addressing it – a bit like trying to wipe out race attacks without acknowledging the violence is about racial superiority!