subscribe: Posts | Comments

Parliamentary aide says people want ‘an abortion-free society’

7 comments

Summary of video from BBC News, 13.01.11.

A UK parliamentary aide, Ed Rennie, has told a radio breakfast show this morning that most people want ‘an abortion-free society’.

Clerk to the all-party parliamentary pro-life group, Rennie told Nicky Campbell on BBC Radio 5 live: “We want to go in a direction where we bring a very tragic practice to an end.”

Presumably in a reference to the news that the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (PAS) is seeking a change in the law to allow women to take pills at home when having an early medical abortion (see WVoN story), Rennie says abortion is a sign of “women’s continued oppression”.

Posing as the champion for women’s liberation, he says that “women’s equality will begin in earnest when we bring women’s oppression to an end”. And that, of course, can only begin when we no longer have abortions.

To my horror, however, I found myself agreeing with Rennie when he said that he wants to see “true equality, authentic equality” between men and women.

Crucially, he also wants to see “men taking responsibility for themselves. We want to be educating men to behave responsibly and abortion is just a free pass for men … they get off scot free”.

Now that I can agree with.

  1. I rather suspect his interpretation of what “authentic equality” means is somewhat different from ours.

    And I really can’t agree with that last comment. Do you want your child growing up in a relationship where the father is only around because you couldn’t have an abortion and he feels some sort of sense of duty?

    Abortion isn’t about men getting off scot free. It’s about women having bodily autonomy, and it’s about only brining children into the world who a truly wanted.

    Yes, men need to contribute more to child rearing and running of households – but that’s a separate issue from abortion.

    • Interesting. Personally, I think it’s important that we educate men to take responsibility for themselves and that includes the consequences of having unprotected sex. I absolutely agree that women should have bodily autonomy but that doesn’t mean that men should not also take some responsibility for the situation.

  2. What I find depressing is there is never any discussion about why women choose to have an abortion whenever the subject comes up. It always seems framed as a woman making a choice to have an abortion because that is just one of a range of options, whereas the reality is that women having children in our society are instantly relegated to second class citizens and if they are single parents they suffer the financial consequences of this and so do the children. Therefore I would like to see the debate framed by how to make it easier for women to have children, rather than making it harder for them to have an abortion.

    • Are you familiar with Morgan Spurlock’s 30 days series? It’s modelled on on his Supersize Me film – he gets someone to do something unusual for 30 days. One of the episodes was a pro-choice campaigner living in a pro-life women’s shelter. It made me think: As much as pro-choice campaigners call themselves pro-choice, they’re campaigning for one particular option rather than actual choice. What the shelter was providing was another option for women: as long as they shared the housework and did something to develop themselves (anything from rehab to night classes) they could stay there with their children for as long as they needed to. Yes, it’s hardly ideal and it doesn’t solve the problem of mothers and single mothers especially being, as you say, second class citizens, but it did give me food for thought.

      (I don’t need to say here that while we should look at making it easier to have children, abortion should continue to be legally and easily available, right?)

      BTW, have you seen today’s CiF on the subject? http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jan/14/drug-induced-abortion-proposal

      • I respectfully disagree with the idea that pro-choice campaigners are campaigning for one particular option rather than choice. Pro-choice is about freedom to choose, without judgement, and for support to be there whatever your decision. It is very much a campaign for choice.

        I think it’s also important to point out that abortion, albeit legal and tolerated in British society, is not all that easily available. Access requires two doctors signing off on a statement regarding the woman’s psychological wellbeing.

        It is my opinion that abortion needs to be available on demand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *