Women oppose changes to state pension age
Summary of story taken from The Guardian, 31/01/2011
According to the Guardian, MPs have been deluged with letters from worried women born in the mid-1950s who were put on notice earlier this month that they will have to work up to two years longer due to the government’s decision to fast-track changes to the pension age.
500,000 women will see their retirement plans affected by more than a year, with 300,000 of this number working an extra 18 months. No men will have to work more than 12 months extra.
The state pension age for women has been gradually increasing since 6 April last year at the rate of one month for every two months the woman was born after 5 April 1950, and was intended to reach 65 by 2020.
Charities are coordinating a grassroots campaign to put pressure on the government to amend the bill when it returns to the house next month.
Labour has also launched a campaign against the policy. The shadow pensions minister, Rachel Reeves, said:
“I understand the implications of increasing longevity, and agree that deficit reduction is a priority, but the legislation is arbitrarily hitting women born in 1954 too harshly, while making no impact on deficit reduction in this parliament.”
“In the most extreme case around 33,000 of these women, including my mother, will have to work for two more years before they get their basic state pension, with only seven years to prepare.”
One Tory backbencher who wished to remain unnamed defended the plans: “We all believe in equality in the workplace, this is part of that.”
















But the Tory backbencher without the balls to put his name to his comment is wrong! This is NOT equality. It states in the article no man will have to work more than one year extra, while women will have to work up to TWO extra years depending on their date of birth. We know that it’s been unfair on men for many many years having to wait until 65 for their retirement but we women in our 50’s who have worked since we left school are not responsible for making those rules. We accepted that it’s fair to make the pension age the same for men and women (fine as long as women get the same rates of pay as men and get taken as seriously in the workplace as men) and we had already accepted some years being added to our retirement age, in my case I was to retire at 64. But this unseemly rush to add years on is totally unfair. I started work when David Cameron was 3 years old, I’m still working now and I’ve paid my contributions every week/month that I have been fortunate enough to earn enough to do so, how much more does he want? Under the timetable set out by the Labour Party this rise in pension age was much better thought out, it brought the change in gradually so that we all did a little bit extra but no-one bore the full brunt – if Cameron gets his way it’s going to be a relatively small group of women who pay for this, we’ll be working until our late sixties, some of us on the sick because we won’t be able to manage, while young people are persecuted for not being able to find jobs. The Tory led government are literally robbing us of our pension and of the freedom that comes with retirement, if anyone else snatched someones pension away they’d be called a mugger. Well if the cap fits David then you’d better wear it.
I’m 63 and already retired so not affected by this proposal but I know women who are and they all have age related complaints which will worsen with time and it will be a struggle to keep on working.Yet with no private pension they will have no choice. . These women have been targeted twice, working to 66 from 15 would mean 51 years of contributions paid in and being robbed of their well earned freedom and a bit of their money back in state pension would be very unfair.
The plan by the last government to introduce the age rise slowly was much fairer and it gave women time to prepare.
It seems to me to be discrimination especially against the women born in 1954.
1 in 5 of 16-24 years olds are unemployed, some have never worked, surely it would make more sense to let older people retire and free up their jobs for younger ones.These young ones are living on benefits which older working people contribute to, even though they have paid nothing in to the system.
This is all wrong !!
I agree with both the above comments. This proposal is so unfair. The Tory MP should have the guts to put his name to his comments. I have been told by Nigel Adams MP that he knows that some women will be badly affected by this proposal but it is a minority. So I assume that makes it OK in his view. We are not asking for a complete U Turn just that the changes are made fairly. There is nothing wrong with Labours plans for increasing the age.
I have never been in a job with a pension scheme nor have I ever earned enough to provide my own, but thought that I was covered by my NI contributions. I accepted the increase to 64 but to have the goalposts moved for a second time for no good reason is devastating. I work 46hrs a week in a manual job, and I know I wont be able to be able to carry on till my late 60s. This Government does not care about us. not only are they saving by not paying our entitlement they expect us to carry on and continue to pay Tax and NI contributions they can’t lose. Then perhaps we can do them another favour and drop off our perches on our 66th birthday.
This government couldn’t give a stuff about women working till they drop dead – after all it will save the state money. This is the result of having Tory government with a cabinet of millionaires – they have no idea.
Jane you’re right, I sincerely hope that women in their 50’s who voted for cameron, voted for clegg, voted for change, voted for tactics or didn’t shift themselves to vote at all are satisfied with the outcome. If this is change then who wants it? Apart from the greedy, corrupt so called government who treat us like an army or worker ants and tread on us when it suits them. I think that cushioned all their lives by inherited money and non physical “work” (I use that term loosely) they have no idea of the life the average person, woman or man, lives and of the worries and resposibilities we have and of how much most of us look forward to being able to officially stop going out to work and watching the clock. Even up the retrement age for women and men, yes of course, but not at the expense of a few unfortunate women born within a short period of time. Slow it down Dave!
This targeting twice of older women is disgraceful. We had no chance of saving for a private pension and we didn’t have equal pay to men.We have paid in our contributions from age 15 in good faith that we would be able to retire at 60, we accepted the age rise on a rolling scale to 65 but to propose 66 as our retiremeent age is asking too much.
We are tired, we have age related complaints and we want some time without the stress of work before we die, which many of us are likedly to do before even seeing a penny of our state pension.
I am a widow, missed out on widows pension, yet others widowed before me have it for life with no worries about going out to work.
To those of us forced to work to be able to live this blow is one too many and I for one feel very depressed about it. .
It is disgraceful to target women born in the mid 1950’s twice. I have accepted the previous change and planned for it but to move the goal posts again and give us only 7 years to plan is disgraceful! I have a sister five years older than me and she started drawing her state pension at the age of 60 – I will have to wait until I am 66! Where is the gradual introduction of new state pension age – someone five years younger can draw her pension six years before I can! this is bullying and discurmination against women!
Couldnt agree more, especially with Mary as my sister is now receiving her pension even though she spent 18 years at home. I started work on my 15th birthday and have paid by stamp all the way through . I went into work after Christmas declaring I had only 6 more years to work,only to be told by my friends that these changes were planned. I was devastated.
What gripes even more is that I understand women who only paid the “married woman’s” stamp are now going to be allowed full pension as well.
This is totally wrong and unfair, whoever thought this up has crunched numbers just for the sake of rushing it through and given no thought to the real lives of the individual women affected, what about the promises made that this wouldn’t happen? Like pie-crust they disappeared once Cameron and his lapdog took over. Why is this trumped up government allowed to change and destroy everything that the ordinary working class woman and man have worked and paid for all their lives? Who actually elected Cameron to be prime minister? Nobody as far as I’m aware, if Clegg hadn’t licked his boots for the chance of a big car and his face on the TV in return for saying yes to every cameron-suggestion this lot wouldn’t be where they are, ruining our lives and our country.
Ladies we need to fight this, we need to stand up and say “NO Dave, actually we think we have done quite enough!”
I echo what these women are saying. We were prevented from paying into private pension schemes when we were younger because of laws which meant part-timers and low wage earners could be excluded . One of the reasons we were low wage earners was because it was then legal for women to be paid considerably less than men for the same work. and we worked part-time or less to bring up the children who are now paying the NI which is paying towards the pensions of women just a few years older than us but to which we will not be entitled at the age these women received it. Steve Clegg is saying the reason we are having our pension withheld for the first 2 years (or almost, depending on which month we were born) therefore losing up to £10,000 is because the government miscalculated how long everyone would live and the country has big debts. I am not suggesting in the least that we should do this as it would be illegal but I wonder what the government would say if we refused to pay 2 years money we owed them because we had miscalculated and had big debts. If we did this regarding our mortgages our homes would be repossessed – big businesses simply would not stand for us not paying them for 2 years. Workers would refuse to work if they were not paid for 2 yearsby their employers. There would be uproar if a private pension scheme refused to pay out pensions at the age they agreed to in the contract yet it is legal for the government to do this to us even though we have paid the full amount required in NI contributions (in some cases in substantial lump sums at the invitation of the state to make up a shortfall of contributions required to receive the full state pension). The government made the mistakes – they had the facilities to work out how long people are likely to live so why is this a bombshell now? – and they mismanaged the economy. Now they want to pass their problems on to women who have been careful to manage their money sensibly. It is possible that this delay in receiving their pensions will mess up their finances so badly it could impact on the rest of their lives. £10,000 may not be much to the government (perhaps that attitude is why they have their financial mess in the first place) but it is a huge amount to the women who will lose it.
I also have worked full time since the age of 15 I was born in 1956, had no time off as I dont have any children and because of some of the jobs I did my hands are now shot !! I have Osteo arthritis and carpel tunnel and wear a splint on one hand and an elastic support on the other just to get through a working day.
We are an easy target for the government its wrong and unfair we need to vacate jobs to allow the younger generation to step in.
There are too many younger people unemployed, these young people some of them dont know what its like to have a job and a wage each week, and unfortunately some never will, they need to work it makes them better prepared to deal with their future and its so unfair they are not going to get the chance.
Women have always been classed as second class citizens in the governments eyes and as already said we are easy targets.
I was born in July 1953. Was due to get my already deferred pension in 2016. Decided in Nov 2010 to give up work from April 2011 due to ill health (cancer), living on my savings until state pension paid. Under this proposal I now have to make my savings last another year – we are told to plan for retirement, which I have, but this late change has made all the planning useless. I have always worked and piad full contributtions from age 16. You now need to have 30 years of contributions to qulaify for full state pension. By the time mine is due I will have piad in for 48 years. The retirement age should be based on how long you have worked as well as age, as those of us who started at 15 or 16 are being penalised. IS ANYONE CO-ORDINATING A PROTEST ON THIS ISSUE?
Unions Together has launched a petition in protest at this proposal and they have had over 500 signatures TODAY
http://www.unionstogether.org.uk/page/signup/handsoff
you can sign it and if you are affected by it you can tell your story and if you give permission they may use your story on their blog, if you then click on my picture (they chose me to represent all of the 500,000 women affected by this, for which I’m greatlyu honoured) you come to my story and then at the bottom you can comment, so you have two chances to have your say.
Ruth, I’m sorry to read of your ill health, yes there is a protest, as well as Unions Together fighting for us Rachel Reeves MP the shadow pensions minister is also tabling an ammendment and lobbying MP’s to back it. Are you on Facebook? If so please consider joining us at http://www.facebook.com/home.php#!/home.php?sk=group_107751495962656&ap=1
I am amazed that no organisation is coordinating a protest of some description, be it online, by a petition or town centre protest marches. This has completely blown a hole my retirement plans, along with my husbands. Being five years younger than him, we would have retired in the same year. Then my retirement age went to 62, now to 66. And MPs do not give a jot, nice.
Christine, please see Barbara’s comment which provides a link to a union petition that has been set up online – http://www.unionstogether.org.uk/page/signup/handsoff
Christine as Alison has pointed out there is a petition by Unions Together available to sign, yesterday afternoon there were 500 signatures added, also Rachel Reeves MP, shadow minister for pensions, gives a hell of a jot because she is fighting for us, as is the Labour party. Meanwhile look again at your retirement age, if you were expecting to retire at 62 I can’t think that you will be required to work to 66 (IF they get the proposal through, which I have to believe we can prevent) It’s those of us born in 53/54 who were expecting to retire at 64 who will be stuck with working to 66 if it happens and we are talking about 2 extra years, not 4 as would be in your case.