England’s top family judge advocates new law for cohabiting couples
Summary from the BBC 03.02.11
The top family judge for England and Wales, Sir Nicholas Wall, has called for new recognition of the rights of unmarried, cohabiting couples in an interview with The Times.
Sir Nicholas, who is president of the High Court’s family division, told The Times that: ‘Women cohabitees, in particular, are seriously disadvantaged by being unable to claim maintenance and having their property rights determined by the conventional laws of trusts.’
He added that the validity of property claims ought to be decided by a judge, and that the courts are likely to be more sympathetic to claims when a couple has cohabited for a long period of time.
He admitted he was disappointed by the lack of government action on this matter.
In his first interview as head of the Division, the judge made it clear that he was not undermining the insitution of marriage, which he stated is still ‘the most stable relationship for bringing up children and for support.’
















Why is it still the case that the onus is on the woman to claim maintenance? It shouldn’t be relationship status that determines whether a woman can claim maintenance for children. The entire system is patriarchal. When a man’s name is put on a birth certificate as the father of a child, it is then that his financial responsibility begins in the eyes of the law. His national insurance number should also be registered at the same time so that if the relationship breaks down and he hasn’t set up adequate approved maintenance arrangements, he should be guilty of breaking the law. If this culture was fed through our legal system, we may not have to concern ourselves so much with the issue of marriage. It is the child’s right to maintainance, not the father’s to evade paying it and neither should it be the mother’s responsibility to spend her life chasing it and wondering whether her relationship status will entitle her to support her children.
Our legal system is so antiquated and so biased towards the male, I’m almost embarrassed by the fact that this is news and will probably receive polite applause from women. It’s clearly a welcome development, but for god’s sake get on with it.
One final point to Sir Nicholas; when he says “…marriage…is still ‘the most stable relationship for bringing up children and for support” can he qualify that this is absolutely not the case where children are brought up in households where there is physical and verbal abuse. The more this government incentivises couples not to divorce (tax breaks for married couples etc), the more cases of abuse in relationships are likely to be suppressed. The more difficult the law makes it for women to become independent and support their children, the more abuse will go unmentioned and women will stay in damaging married relationships for fear of what poverty and lack of support will look like.
I applaud the courts for looking for ways to protect vulnerable women. And I’m saying this as a child-free professional woman.
But… I have chosen not to get married but to live with my partner. And one of the many reasons for this is that I don’t want to be a “wife”, I want to retain my individuality and independence. I’m quite happy for the benefits system to judge us as a household, but in other ways, surely it’s my decision whether I get married? This assumption that a judge determining people’s relationship status for them will protect women seems really rather patronising to me.
Women have the ability to protect their own property and income, we don’t need judges, courts or the state to automatically protect us. Surely we (along with our partners) can choose whether we want to have a state-sanctioned and protected relationship or not?