subscribe: Posts | Comments

Media continues to deny existence of glass ceiling

3 comments

Summary of story from Women’s eNews, 22.2.11.

A recently published study about women in sciences concluded that women are held back by their own choices, not by discrimination.

The researchers, Stephen J. Ceci and Wendy M. Williams, claim that women’s underrepresentation in science is down to women’s lifestyle and career preferences, which include caring for elderly relatives and children, working part-time, and moving to be with a partner.

Ceci and Williams’ findings were collected in the paper “Understanding Current Causes of Women’s Underrepresentation in Science’ and published in the respected journal “Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences” on 7 February.

The results have been widely reported, featuring in Nature, the New York Times and the Guardian.

The Washington Post declared that the article was a “stunning critique of research on bias against women.”

Suspicious? You should be.

WeNews has now published a critique of the article, highlighting serious flaws in its methodology that media commentators have chosen to ignore.

It appears that the researchers failed to take account of significant studies already done on the subject which concluded that in fact, gender bias was alive and well in science and engineering.

Ceci and Williams’ study also ignored widespread discrimination recorded against women who had been impeded in their advancement, but who had not made the lifestyle choices that they claim cause women’s underrepresentation at a high level in academic science.

Finally, their conclusions are based on very limited data; they concentrate on minor issues such as grant funding, at the expense of much more significant problems, such as discrimination at the hiring stage.

It seems that even science reporters don’t want to let the facts get in the way of a good story.

  1. I wouldn’t call caring for relatives a life style “preference.” It’s something that has to be done out of a sense of decency.

    • Hi Claire, I agree with you, of course, that caring for relatives isn’t a ‘preference’. It’s something you do as a response to a relative’s need that is motivated by basic human compassion.

      I used that phrasing to reflect the way in which Ceci and Williams (and many apologists for discrimination and sexism) try to mask the social origins of discrimination against women by making it look like the outcome of choices that women have made freely.

      What you have picked up on is one of the central flaws in their argument, aside from the methodological criticisms in the WeNews article – they attribute too much agency to women, when in fact women are often restricted in their career progression by employers’ inflexible attitudes towards caring responsibilities that tend to fall to women.

      I hope you didn’t think I used the word ‘preference’ because that was how I viewed caring; on reflection, perhaps I ought to have put it in inverted commas to emphasise that I was being a bit sarcastic. I know from my family’s experience that caring for relatives is often inconvenient and upsetting – certainly not something you would describe as a ‘preference’.

  2. vicki wharton says:

    And doesn’t explain why men’s lifestyle choices, such as getting married, having children and parents, doesn’t impeed them in a similar way …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *