Big Fat Wedding show ignores poverty in the UK Traveller community
Summary of an article in the Guardian, 25.02.11
A UK television show about Roma and Traveller brides failed to deal with Traveller women’s realities says journalist Julie Bindel in the Guardian today.
Channel 4 series “My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding” focused on the glitz and glamour of weddings in the two communities.
“But,” writes Bindel, “the show largely avoided the myriad of problems, such as discrimination, poor health and poverty faced by Travellers, except for what felt like a tokenistic final episode.”
There are around 300,000 Roma and Travellers in Britain. The Roma come from Northern India but have lived in Europe for centuries. Travellers originate from Ireland. In the UK both groups are traditionally nomadic but many families live on permanent caravan sites and some in houses.
Bindel writes that Travellers are three times more likely to miscarry or have a stillborn child than other British women. Poor sanitation and lack of clean water on Traveller caravan sites are among the factors thought to blame.
Plans to spend £50 million on new sites across London were scrapped by the British government last year.
Similarly there is little culturally-specific provision for victims of domestic violence. There is just one 10-room refuge for Traveller women in the United Kingdom.
Bindel spoke to domestic violence worker Bernie O’Roarke who expects to be the only Traveller liaison worker left in London after funding cuts.
The women interviewed by Bindel agree that “My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding” has increased prejudice against Travellers, which has been widespread for centuries.
“I don’t know anyone so rich that they can afford to splash out on wedding dresses like that. Mine was secondhand. They’ll now be saying we are all criminals, or sponging off the state,” says Helen, a woman in her 20s.
Teenager Mary notes: “That programme didn’t show the real way we go on. All my friends are asking if it’s true what they show on telly, and I think they’ve gone different [towards me] since it was shown.”
O’Roarke worries: “That TV programme has put our work back 100 years. And if these women lose the little support they have, they literally will be left to rot.”
















I don’t think the difficult position of traveller women was lost on the average viewer. And the programme did highlight the inequality between the sexes whereas the commentators don’t seem to be. Also girls being kept from school to work doesn’t seem to have raised any concerns amongst the commentators either?