subscribe: Posts | Comments

Recruitment transparency will help boardroom gender disparity

0 comments

Summary of story from The Observer, 20.02.11 and comment

A review on gender equality in boardrooms, which will be delivered to the UK government this week, will recommend more transparency in the recruitment process of company directors.

Currently only 12.2 per cent of women hold positions as directors of FTSE 100 companies, only five of these are chief executives.

The review is led by Labour peer Lord Davies of Abersoch, who told The Observer, “chairmen have got to be more creative in looking for talented women”.

The review will reject legally compulsory quotas which require 40 per cent of board directors to be women, such as those in Norway and Iceland.

Although some commentators agree that women in the boardroom help companies succeed, only 11 per cent of the 2,600 people who responded to Lord Davies’ ‘Women on Boards‘ consultation, favoured legal enforcement of a gender quota on boards in the UK.

Why?

The Institute of Directors responded to the consultation by calling quotas “demeaning” to women. Instead, they advocated a more nurturing approach, with mentoring and other schemes to support women in their progress to the end goal of becoming director.

Sheryl Sandberg, the CEO of Facebook, spoke at TEDWomen about what slowed women down in their career paths, including that they take their “foot off the pedal” as soon as they think about settling down with a family.

Listening to Sheryl, it is easy to see how the nurturing tack could give women a boost.

Personally I am glad that Lord Davies is going down the recruitment monitoring route.

I had a discussion about recruitment with the hosts of TEDWomen, who found that people were more likely to recommend female speakers they knew if they were specifically asked for females. However, if they are asked merely for a speaker, they were more likely to propose a man.

This anecdote implies that Lord Davies is right, recruitment does need to be a more “creative” process.

The first choice for any number of board level positions might be a man because they might be the first person that springs to mind. Ask for women at the recruitment stage, and suddenly qualified and talented women might come out of the woodwork.

In Norway, it appears that the quotas have done just that. Elin Hurvenes, head of the Professional Boards Forum advisory service in Norway and the UK told the Financial Times that: “A 63-year-old Norwegian chairman said to me: ‘I had no idea there was such an abundance of suitable women. This has really opened my eyes.’ ”

I really hope that Lord Davies’ proposals are enough to encourage a shift in corporate culture without resorting to quotas.

There is still the possibility, however, that quotas might be necessary in the future if recruitment monitoring does not improve the gender balance around some of the most powerful tables in the country.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *