subscribe: Posts | Comments

Women warned against reducing red meat consumption

0 comments

Summary of story from Daily Telegraph, 22.2.11.

The latest Government advice, backed by strong scientific research, suggests that cutting down on red meat can reduce the risk of developing bowel cancer (see Telegraph, 21.2.11).

However, a dietician has now claimed that women of reproductive age should be wary of reducing their meat intake, because it may greaten their risk of developing iron-deficiency anaemia.

Dr Carrie Ruxton, a dietician and member of the Meat Advisory Panel, said:

“We’ve already got 50 per cent of women in this country who have iron intakes below the absolute minimum in your diet. Are we going to have more women who are going to be iron deficient because of this sort of advice?”

When reading pro-meat scare stories such as this, it is worth keeping in mind the research of Dr Kathryn Clancy, Assistant Professor of Anthropology at the University of Illinois (here, via The F Word).

Dr Clancy’s work indicates that women are not prone to iron deficiency simply because they have periods, and that this commonly-held belief is based on false assumptions about the female body.

The belief that, as Dr Clancy puts it, women are ‘pathological just by being female’, can in some cases lead to misdiagnosis of more serious conditions.

Women considering reducing their meat intake would do better than to listen to members of the biased Meat Advisory Panel, who rely on dubious science to prove a point.

There is now strong evidence that eating less meat is better not just good for animals and the planet, but for our health, regardless of gender.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *