Women, work and the glass ceiling – balancing happiness, careers, flexibility and family
By Jo Middleton
WVoN co-editor
My week so far has been an excellent example of why flexible working is so important for parents, illness particularly women.
I have two children, mind aged eight and fifteen, and due to various stomach/head/throat-related illnesses, today is the first day when both children have managed to make it to school.
Fortunately, I am self-employed, working from home, and have been able to juggle work with caring for sick children, but not everyone is so lucky…
Yesterday we reported on comments made by UK public sector union Unison, who claim that increased flexible working opportunities could be what it takes for women to break through the glass ceiling and access more senior positions in the workplace.
Unison believes that it’s not just the flexible working itself that is crucial, but the attitudes that go with it. Currently they say, flexible working is seen as the ‘mummy track’, with many employers showing very little respect for what they perceive as women choosing to put family before their career.
The comments come on the back of a report from Opportunity Now, a UK membership organisation for employers committed to creating an inclusive workplace for women.The research, titled ‘What holds women back?’ looks at what both men and women understand of the barriers to women’s progression at work.
Following on from research conducted in 2005, one of the most worrying findings is that during that time, neither the barriers to progression nor individual perceptions of it appear to have changed for the better.
The findings also show quite strikingly that men are far less appreciative of the barriers and attitudes that restrict women’s career development.
The report found for example that 82% of women, compared to just 54% of men, recognised the need to balance work and family life as a barrier to progression, and while 49% of women see stereotyping and preconceptions about women’s skills and abilities as a barrier, only 14% of men are aware of this as an issue.
“Some women feel exhausted by the battles they face in the workplace,” says one female manager, interviewed for the study, “especially when they choose to work flexibly to manage work/life balance.
“There is also the problem of ‘long hours culture’. As a wife and mother I work extremely hard to balance my time and simply cannot work excessive hours.”
There are clearly still deeply ingrained gender stereotypes within business, as another female manager explained.
“I’ve been told a number of times recently that women get ahead because they flirt their way, or sleep with their boss. Also that management pander to women because they can ‘screw up’ a man’s career very easily i.e. start an harassment case because they’re annoyed!”
This prejudice acts directly as a barrier to women’s career progression. “These sorts of attitudes still exist and make it difficult for women to put up with work environments over a long period of time, meaning they don’t get promoted.”
Although many women now are able to benefit from flexible or part-time working, the assumption that part-time working equates to a lack of commitment to a role still inhibits women’s career development.
“Flexible hours and family responsibility are the most significant barriers I have experienced,” says one female manager.
“As a highly qualified manager I am excluded from opportunities to progress on the basis that the vast majority of positions at management level require full time hours.”
As much as people may like to believe women have achieved equality, there is still clearly a massive underrepresentation of women in senior positions in business.
The Corporate Women Directors International 2010 Report, which looks at the gender balance in the leadership of the 200 largest companies in the world, found that while over three-quarters do now have at least one female director on their board, men still hold 87.8% of all board appointments.
And the UK is one of the worst culprits – all countries with at least five companies in the Fortune Global 200 in 2009 increased their percentage of women directors, with one exception – the United Kingdom. The UK saw a drop in the percentage of women board directors in the companies included in the Fortune listing from 13.9% to 10.6%.
So what can be done? Is there a flexible working solution that is supportive of family life whilst still being cost-effective for organisations, or is it the case that big business requires a time commitment that many women simply don’t want or aren’t able to give?
There are of course some employers who already realise the benefits of flexible working, both in terms of individual employee well-being and the impact on an organisation’s productivity.
Cuddledry is a successful retail company, set up by two working mums, Polly Marsh and Helen Wooldridge, in 2006. With six children between them, Helen and Polly appreciate how important it is for parents to be able to balance work and family life.
“We were realistic about our own strengths,” says Polly, “and have a unique business plan in that we actively seek to employ home based personnel. We have discovered that like us, there are many parents who are no longer able or wish to work full time in high powered roles due to family commitments.
“Many of these people have given up very senior roles and are highly qualified, intelligent people, but are unable to find a part time or flexible job to suit their abilities. They need a role to be flexible and usually home based, in order to continue their careers at the same level.
“Many part time or flexible roles on offer are at a much reduced level of seniority or responsibility. We do not believe this has to be the case and offer flexible part time roles where each person is absolutely the head of their own department within an expanding successful company.”
In doing this, Helen and Polly have challenged the assumption that a ‘lifestyle’ or home business, using flexible, home-based employees, cannot also be highly profitable.
With such a forward-thinking attitude as this it is hardly surprising that Cuddledry won the award for Remote Employer of the Year in 2009.
The flip side of the argument of course is that although women may be trailing behind in terms of power and money, surveys repeatedly show women to be happier overall in their work.
So do the benefits of working part-time in positions of less responsibility outweigh the lower pay?
All those male company directors may be feeling powerful and making big bucks, but are they secretly all miserable, wishing they could work fewer hours and spend more time with their families?
Whatever the case, there is clearly still a long way to go to achieving at least equality of access to opportunity, and it is crucial that we consider all the options for ensuring women are able to make a positive contribution to work, not just for personal reasons, but for the benefit of the economy as a whole.
“It is depressing that women still pay a career penalty for having a family, “ concludes the Opportunity Now report. “Some will cite “choice” and suggest that sacrificing progression at work for a family life is an acceptable trade off but it is one that leaves organisations and the UK as a whole poorer.
“The implications of failing to address this issue go far beyond the disappointments and frustrations of these women’s careers.
“We risk wasting the talents of another generation of women and leaving the board rooms of UK organisations without the diversity of skills, talents and experiences that will enrich decision making, enhance innovation and make the UK more competitive in the future.”
















As a mother of a young child and a full time grad student with serious career goals, I found this article to be a reminder that I am not alone, and that I am not wrong. Thanks for the reminder that there is still much to be done to achieve gender equality in the workplace.
Of course only 14% of men see stereotyping of women’s skills as a barrier to women’s success – the other 86% are the ones that are stereotyping!! Depressing proof that discrimination is alive and flourishing in the UK …
Great article Jo, thanks for including so many great references to research.
The difficulty of combining motherhood with working is something that we still haven’t, as a society, addressed. And it’s an issue that overlaps with so many areas, particularly employment.
There’s a fundamental problem in that we don’t really value women as mothers (or we’d recognise the huge contribution they make as parents and carers) in our society, and we don’t value women as workers. Yet we consistently expect them to be both!