subscribe: Posts | Comments

A seedy new neighbourhood for the web: XXX domain approved

1 comment

Summary of  story: The Business Insider, March 18 2011

The Internet is about to get a seedy new neighbourhood. The body governing top-level Internet domains has approved a new .xxx domain for porn, despite objections from the adult entertainment industry.

The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) concluded its annual meeting in San Francisco yesterday, and voted 9-3 to approve the .xxx domain.

The idea for the domain has been kicking around for almost a decade, and was approved briefly in 2005, but this decision was reversed a couple of years later.

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC), which represents some businesses in the adult industry, opposed the adult domain because it would raise costs for porn providers, who will now have to register additional .xxx domain names at $60 a pop to avoid having their brands hijacked.

Many adult entertainment companies own hundreds or thousands of addresses, so this is a significant cost.

The FSC also claimed that the new domain will make it easier for filters to block adult sites.

Yesterday, the organization sponsored a rally in San Francisco outside the hotel where ICANN was having its meeting, but the demonstration apparently didn’t work.

Today, the FSC said it would appeal the decision to an advisory board consisting of government representatives.

WVON co-editor comment: Firstly, my heart bleeds for the pornography industry – how terrible that it might have to shell out a slice of its $13billion (Observer, 2007) profit to purchase a new domain name.

More seriously, this is an interesting move. In the absence of a complete ban on pornography, I think I can support the idea of a ring-fenced area on the internet for porn, especially if it is also behind a paywall.  At the very least the ability to more easily filter the sites may minimise the inadvertent exposure of ‘pornographied’ images of women to young people. What do people think?

  1. The problem you would have is who defines ‘porographied’, is the image of a fully clothed (neck->feet) woman porn, one wearing underwear (say advertising bras / briefs), one wearing a swimsuit (generally more skin tight than bra / briefs)… Depending on whose version of ‘pornographied’ you apply we get differing results and especially if you consider the global nature of the internet, what is ‘pornographied’ here might be acceptable elsewhere and the reverse also true.

    As for applying the .xxx it makes some sense to have top level domains defined like this however it is not going to get utilised this way. There are already too many top level domains and most simply result in corporations having to purchase their name again. I have no doubt we will see Microsoft.xxx, apple.xxx etc simply to stop these getting used in other ways. While the idea of separating out porn from the regular net is laudable it is already easy to avoid if you don’t wish to see it (and you can avoid ads ets at the same time so double bonus).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *