subscribe: Posts | Comments

Headhunters suffer failure of imagination

0 comments

Original story The Telegraph 19 March 2011

Headhunters are refusing to back UK Government proposals to double the number of women on boards by 2015 – yet search firms are supposed to play a critical role in the process.

According to a study carried out by InterExec, some 65 per cent of headhunters disagree with Lord Davies’ report. Published last month, it said companies should be aiming to at least double the number of women they hire into boardroom positions (see WVoN story).

Currently just 12.5 per cent of board positions in the FTSE 100 are held by women. The Government aims to increase this to at least 25 per cent in just four years time.

In a Government-commissioned report, Lord Davies, a former UK trade minister, said that one-in-three of all UK board appointments must be female to achieve the voluntary target set for 2015. That equates to hiring 135 women.

Headhunters disagree that voluntary targets should be set – despite them being expected to play a vital role in getting more women on senior shortlists.

Among his proposals, Lord Davies urged search firms to cast the net far wider than they currently do to identify talented females, drawing up shortlists including women entrepreneurs, academics and civil servants.

As Lord Davies said, headhunters tended to focus on women with financial backgrounds or who had served on executive committees.

The InterExec research also found 89 per cent believe there is a danger Lord Davies’ recommendations will result in some optimal candidates being turned down as a result of positive discrimination.

Kit Scott-Brown, managing director of InterExec, said: “I think it would be a crying shame if the best candidate didn’t get the job, completely regardless of their age, sex, colour or creed. It should be skills, experience and aptitude for the job that count.

“Unfortunately, positive discrimination will inevitably mean that the best candidate could lose out on a board room position, which I feel is wrong.”

In a press briefing, Lord Davies disputed the idea that there were simply not enough women capable of taking up senior board roles. He urged companies and recruiters to think more imaginatively about how to hire the most talented females.

WVoN co-editor comment: perhaps every woman who has applied for a position on a board and is rejected should make this public?  It is too simplistic to keep trotting out ‘there aren’t enough women around’: this cannot be true, can it?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *