Illegal immigrants fight for return of daughter, a US citizen
Summary of story from The New York Times, March 22, 2011
Four year-old Emily Ruiz, a US citizen, was travelling home from a trip to Guatemala with her grandfather, when he was denied entry back into the United States.
Emily’s grandfather holds a valid work visa but was refused entry owing to an immigration infraction from two decades ago.
Emily’s father, Leonel Ruiz, and mother, Brenda Dubon, live and work in the United States illegally. Emily, however, was born in the country and is a United States citizen.
Emily and her grandfather were forced to return to Guatemala, and her parents are now struggling to bring their daughter home.
The Ruizes find themselves on the front lines of a heated immigration debate: how to treat illegal immigrants whose children are American-born citizens.
“She was treated like a second-class citizen or worse,” said David M. Sperling, the Ruiz’s lawyer. “She’s a US citizen, and she’s entitled to the same rights as any other US citizen.”
But some US officials have pushed for bills to end automatic citizenship for children who are born in the USA, children sometimes referred to pejoratively as “anchor babies.”
Last week, the state of Arizona rejected a measure aimed at pushing the Supreme Court to rule against automatic citizenship for American children born to illegal immigrants.
But elected officials in other states, like Kansas and California, have also shown a desire to change the law and make it harder for such children to stay in the US.
Immigration advocates have used the Ruiz case as an example of what may come if new citizen legislation is enacted.
“The case is alarming because it shows what can happen once you start treating kids who are born here whose parents are undocumented with less rights than a full-blown citizen,” said Jeanne A. Butterfield, a former executive director of the American Immigration Lawyers Association.
Emily had been sent to Guatemala for the winter because her parents were afraid the cold weather would irritate her asthma.
“This is very unfair because she is a citizen,” Mr Ruiz said, “and she is a very little girl.”











