Miral – a Palestinian tale: the other side of Exodus
Summary of story from AlJazeera, March 27, 2011
The film Miral, a Palestinian tale based on the autobiography of one woman, Rula Jebreal, is about three generations of women.
‘Miral’ also marks the first time anyone has tried to tell just a Palestinian story in Hollywood.
Telling the Palestinian side of the story – not telling the story from both sides – was precisely the point of the movie, and the book it is based on.
It is not clear what exactly has overheated the critics, many of whom have not even seen the film.
Could it be the black and white images of Jewish refugees near the film’s opening – accompanied not by familiar swelling music but by dark, minor strains, a kind of foreboding for Palestinians in the 1940s who opposed the Jewish influx from Europe?
Could it be the 1948 encounter between a young Palestinian woman in Jerusalem’s Old City with children who survived the massacre at Deir Yassin?
Or the picture of an Israeli steam shovel demolishing a Palestinian home in 1967?
Or the Palestinian children staring through the window of a bus travelling through the West Bank, at the ever-sprouting hilltop Jewish settlements?
Or this line about the settlers from a Palestinian protagonist: “What they really want is all of Palestine, without the Palestinians”?
Or perhaps it is much more primal than that.
Jennifer Jajeh, the Palestinian-American author of the provocative one-woman show, I Heart Hamas, wondered playfully at a Miral premiere party in Los Angeles this week: “What’s the problem? Is it because the rebel guy is cute?”
Most Americans, Jew and Gentile, grew up with the Leon Uris history of the struggle for the Holy Land.
Exodus chronicles the heroic birth of Israel out of the ashes of the Holocaust.
There the story ends; there is no other narrative.
So it could be that.











