subscribe: Posts | Comments

US Supreme Court wavers over Walmart sex discrimination lawsuit

0 comments

Summary of story from The Columbus Dispatch, March 30, 2011

The US Supreme Court appears ready to block a massive sexual discrimination lawsuit against Walmart, on behalf of up to 1.6 million women.

The decision could also make it harder for other workers to bring class-action claims against large employers.

The 10-year-old lawsuit, argued in lively exchanges at the court, claims that Walmart Stores, the world’s largest employer, favours men over women in pay and promotions (see WVoN story.)

The case could affect other class-action lawsuits that pool modest individual claims into a single action, creating the potential for a big judgment and increasing the pressure to settle.

Several justices have suggested they were troubled by the case and lower-court decisions against Bentonville, Arkansas-based Walmart.

Estimates of how many women could be included in the lawsuit run from 500,000 to 1.6 million. Billions of dollars could be at stake.

Justice Anthony Kennedy found fault with the women’s argument in the lawsuit:

“You said this is a culture where Arkansas knows … everything that’s going on,” Kennedy said to Joseph Sellers, the women’s attorney.

“Then in the next breath, you say, well, now these supervisors have too much discretion. It seems to me there’s an inconsistency there, and I’m just not sure what the unlawful policy is.”

Sellers said that lower courts had been persuaded by statistical and other evidence. He said Walmart’s corporate culture stereotypes women as less aggressive, and that translates into pay and promotion decisions at Walmart and Sam’s Club stores across the US.

“The decisions are informed by the values the company provides,” Sellers said.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said the issue is not proving discrimination but showing enough evidence to go forward. Justices Stephen Breyer, Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor also seemed inclined to allow the case to proceed.

But several of their more conservative colleagues seemed to agree with Theodore Boutrous Jr., Walmart’s attorney. He said the class-action nature of the case is unfair because it forces Walmart to defend the treatment of female employees regardless of their job or location.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *