subscribe: Posts | Comments

Working the night shift: women in India’s call center industry

0 comments

Alison Clarke
WVoN co-editor

“Call center job equals call girl job!

“What kind of work are these females doing at night?

“Who will marry her?”

These are just some of the remarks made to Reena Patel while researching her first book, Working the Night Shift: Women in India’s Call Center Industry.

What follows is a fascinating account of how India’s rapidly expanding call centers affects the lives of women workers.

Relatively high wages and the opportunity to be part of an upscale, globalized work environment draw many in India to the call center industry.

At the same time, night shift employment presents women, in particular, with new challenges as well as opportunities.

Working the Night Shift is the first in-depth study of the call center industry written from the point of view of women workers.

It uncovers how call center employment affects their lives, mainly as it relates to the anxiety that Indian society has about women going out at night, earning a good salary, and being exposed to western culture.

This timely account illustrates the ironic and, at times, unsettling experiences of women who pursue call center employment, often to their families’ shame.

And in some instances, to the disdain of “nosy neighbors” who worry that having women going out and about during the night will give their neighborhood a “bad reputation”.

Dr Patel also explores how the industry has the potential to disrupt societal expectations, such as arranged marriages.

Suggesting that call center employment disrupts this ago-old tradition, one woman said, “The call center becomes our marriage pool!,” while other women suggested that working at night provided a means to avoid being placed on an arranged marriage market by their families.

In Bangalore, the author interviewed one twenty-four-year-old man who referred to the night shift as “the hooker shift.”

When asked how call center employment intersects with arranged marriage, he said: “If the guy finds out after this arranged marriage thing that, you know, the girl is not all that, the way she’s supposed to be or the way he expected her to be, and she says, “I want to go and work,” he would probably say yes first.

“Thinking about the math and all that, getting in the salary, double income, all that works, in a sense he might say yes.

“Then what if she starts earning more? Then this guy is done for.

“He knows that he should be the primary breadwinner and if he cannot be that, that’s it. The reasons could be many [for why] he doubts his wife, that even can come up between the husband and wife.

“This guy could say, if she comes home late, he could accuse her of sleeping with somebody else.

If he is not able to be the primary contributor to family income, he cannot survive. His ego will eat him up”.

This “ego issue”—which one woman in the book candidly referred to as her husband’s “inferiority complex” — has done little, it seems,  to change gender roles in the household.

According to Dr Patel, it was apparent that call center employment income does not translate into a demand for change in gender roles at home.

Women did not insist that their husbands, fathers, or brothers take an active role in cooking, cleaning, and child-rearing.

The men, in the meantime, avoided the drudgery of housework under the excuse that it is “ladies’ work” and that to take on such work would emasculate them.

Although the book is primarily an account of what women workers think of India’s rapidly expanding call center industry, Dr Patel also reflects on what it was like for her personally—as a single, child-free, 36-year old American woman of Indian origin—to live to India.

Rather than carrying the sentiment of returning to her homeland, for example, she candidly shares both her disappointment and frustration with living in a society in which “Do you live with your husband?” and “Why aren’t you married?” were part and parcel of how individuals in her neighborhood approached her.

Working the Night Shift: Women in India’s Call Center Industry by Reena Patel, PhD. Published by Stanford University Press and available from Amazon.com.

For more information, visit the author’s website: www.working-the-nightshift.com and Facebook Page.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *