subscribe: Posts | Comments

Belle de Jour, her real name and her new book

4 comments

Summary and comment from The Observer April 10, 2011

The woman who published two books under the pseudonym ‘Belle de Jour’ about her experiences of working as a £300-an-hour prostitute in London, is writing a third book.

Sexonomics: An Examination of Third-Wave Feminism Through the Prism of the Sex Trade, will be the first publication under her real name, Dr Brooke Magnanti.

The book will revisit the long-discussed issue of whether it is a woman’s choice to sell sex, or a deeply exploitative role that they are driven into by poverty and an abusive, male-dominated society – the exploiter or the exploited.

“As a former sex worker, I think you’ll guess my position,” she says.

Magnanti worked as a prostitute for 14 months between 2003-2004 to support herself while doing her degree and subsequent doctorate. Her true identity was revealed in 2009.

Immediately afterwards Magnanti found herself under attack, accused of pushing the male fantasy of prostitution – a glamorous sex bomb in stockings who loved her work – and of ignoring the fact that many sex workers live unsafe and substance-addicted lives, often with an abusive man in tow.

“Up until November 2009, I would have said I was a feminist,” she said, “then I found out the hard way that feminism in this country is like the Ivy League, it’s mostly filled with the sort of people you spent your school years avoiding”.

It’s pretty clear that Magnanti is speaking from a position of privilege.

Free to write under her own name in national, well-respected newspapers, she  has no fear for her professional reputation (she now works as a research scientist at Bristol University).

She ignores her position in society to justify her very limited understanding of feminism.

“I genuinely do not get the third-wave bluestocking professional feminists in this country. Genuinely,” she says.

“I’ve tried to give a shit about maternity leave and who does the housework, and all I can come up with is, if your job doesn’t give you as much time off as you want, suck it up or get another job. If your partner doesn’t do the washing-up, same.”

Again, a complete surface-reading of feminism. There are feminists fighting daily for political representation and respect, for jobs in public and voluntary sectors, feminists are trying to revitalise education, feminists run workshops and training courses.

Feminism is not an issue of identity, it is a global movement to end sexism, sexist exploitation and oppression.

Magnanti’s main defence, other than ‘choice’, is that she has never advocated prostitution as a career for others.

“I spend about half of my email time every day discouraging people clearly unsuited to the job from doing it. I’d be interested to know how many of my critics have actually successfully talked anyone out of sex work, because I do it all the damn time.”

Interestingly, she does not quantify what she means by ‘unsuited’.

Sexonomics: An Examination of Third-Wave Feminism Through the Prism of the Sex Trade is due for release next spring.

For more information on sex work and the surrounding laws and campaigns, go to the International Prostitutes Collective.

  1. Karen Whiteley says:

    For an academic, Magnanti’s thoughts on feminism are pretty basic. I’d be interested to know whether, if Magnanti had a daughter, she would be ‘unsuited’ to sex work. Presumably not, as it’s such a wonderfully ’empowering’ choice for women. Oh, she makes me despair.

    • Good point Karen. Also, as an academic I am appalled. As the article points out, she is speaking from a position of privilege and being an academic – for me and all the other academics I work with – is all about recognising your own position in relation to others before you start pontificating.

      Further, an academic cannot hope to write knowledgeably any subject if he/she/they know nothing about it – which is obviously the case here. It doesn’t even sound as if she has done even a cursory literature search, which is the baseline of good research – which looks at what has already been said in the field, who said it, who agrees, disagrees, what does my research say, discuss this and draw a conclusion.

      This kind of proper consideration does not result a conclusion of “I’ve tried to give a shit about maternity leave and who does the housework, and all I can come up with is, if your job doesn’t give you as much time off as you want, suck it up or get another job. If your partner doesn’t do the washing-up, same.” and ‘I genuinely do not get the third-wave bluestocking professional feminists in this country.” Unbelievable.

      • Agreed, it’s a completely defensive reaction. If she has an issue with some individuals, then she should speak with them about her decisions, but to position herself so anti-feminist whilst clearly misrepresenting feminism is very foolish (and a bit confusing).

  2. “I spend about half of my email time every day discouraging people clearly unsuited to the job from doing it. I’d be interested to know how many of my critics have actually successfully talked anyone out of sex work, because I do it all the damn time.”

    Actually, she spends 75% of her time trying to convince everyone that “Hey, prostitution is no different from being a waitress! It’s just a job, no big deal!” Uh-huh. Which is why she spends “50% of her time” convincing people not to go into it. Make no mistake- she fully understands that there is something wrong with prostitution. Too bad she justifies her choices to herself (i.e. flounders around trying to protect her ego) by being dishonest to everyone, including herself.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *