‘Feminism has held back working men’ says UK Universities Minister
Comment and summary of stories from The Telegraph, April 1, 2011 and BBC, April 2, 2011
A UK government report on social mobility (sadly not an April Fool’s day joke) has concluded that movement between the classes has “stagnated” over the past 40 years.
In the report, to be published next week, Universities Minister David Willetts astonishingly blames the entry of women into the workplace and universities for the lack of progress of men.
Yes, you did read that correctly. By going to university, or to work you have held back men.
Willetts conveniently manages to ignore the more obvious fact that misogyny and sexism throughout history have significantly hindered the social mobility of women, and instead focused on that oft-underserved and discriminated against group: men.
“Feminism trumped egalitarianism” he said, referring to women who otherwise might have remained housewives taking university places and well-paid jobs that could instead have gone to ambitious working-class men.
The minister set out these views during a briefing with journalists on the government’s social mobility strategy.
When asked what he believed was to blame for the lack of social mobility, Willetts said: “The feminist revolution in its first round effects was probably the key factor.”
Although Willetts does go on to say that he is “not against feminism” this will leave a bitter taste in the mouth for the huge number of women who have been more negatively affected by the coalition’s Comprehensive Spending Review than their male counterparts.
In the past eight months unemployment amongst women has risen, whereas male unemployment has been falling for more than a year (see WVoN story).
The BBC reports that the British labour party has now leapt into the fray and demanded that he withdraw the comments.
Yvette Cooper, who is both shadow home secretary and shadow minister for women and equalities, said: “Now we see why this Tory-led government is hitting women twice as hard as men.
“Instead of addressing the problems and disadvantages low-income families face, senior Tory ministers have decided women and feminism are to blame.”
She added: “David Willetts should quickly withdraw this rubbish and face up to the real problems his policies are causing for young people and women who want to get on.”
Well-known British academic and feminist Joni Lovenduski pointed out that: “This is a good example of the hypocrisy of comfortably placed middle class men claiming that women are to blame for a situation that has long preceded women’s entry into politics”.
Added 0n April 3, 2011: if you want to read an even better demolition job of these ridiculous assertions, read this post of the same date on the Grains of Truth blogspot.
















I saw this article yesterday. Being the 1st April I honestly believed (as did so many other people) that it was an April Fools joke by the paper.
To blame women for delaying men’s progress because we ‘entered” the workplace just demonstrates what idiots hold positions of so called ‘expertise’. How did he get his job? No, best not to answer that…
I saw this tweet from @pennyred ‘Willetts has form for this. In his book he blames women for destroying the welfare system by selfishly refusing to rely on men to keep them’
What to do ladies?
Cecilia: I really don’t know what to say.
What an unbelievable moron. He should be fired and possibly tested by a doctor for impaired cognitive function.
Excluding half the population from education and the work force holds it back. Cavemen like this hold it back. Forcing half the population into positions of silence and oppression hold it back. Ignorance under the all-purpose excuse of patrimonial religious domination, led by morons like this who would have us all sold into marriage and breeding by 14 (like Canada’s polygamous community of Bountiful), hold it back.
The good news is cavemen like this are a dying breed. The more I accomplish, the more I work, the more I choose for myself, the more my equally-hard-working husband respects me and adores me. And well he should because I rock.
Were we reading the same article? The Telegraph article gave a reasonable argument, I think. We can’t deny that having more women in the workplace will have had some effect on men, but that doesn’t mean we should rewind the feminist movement. We shouldn’t just decry those who say uncomfortable things or we lay ourselves open to those who claim “it’s political correctness gone mad” and we discredit our cause.
My husband and I both work the same, part time hours and share childcare and housework, we both struggle with the workload. In my ideal world, couples would still be working the same number of total hours they did when women stayed at home but between them and mortgages would still be based on multiples of one full time salary rather than two, which has pushed house prices up to such a ridiculous level.
Hi Angela, thanks for your comment. Yes, I wonder if we are all reading the same article because although I accept we shouldn’t just “decry those who say uncomfortable things”, I think it’s right to take issue with politicians who say completely nonsensical things.
First of all, social mobility is a complex concept that has many ingredients – including where you live, where you go to school, whether your parents are interested in you/your education and so on. Willetts does not appear to think that any of those things have an impact on social mobility.
Instead, he picks on feminism as being a cause for the lack of social mobility for working “men” (apparently it didn’t have an impact on working women or maybe he doesn’t think they matter). Surely if he cares about social mobility, he would care about social mobility for everyone, not just one group that he picks out.
The other – rather obvious – point to ask is why he doesn’t mention the impact of middle and upper class men (as feminism seems to be a byword for middle and upper class women) on working men? If they don’t have an impact then why do women.
The answer, of course, is because the underlying political ideology here is that women should stay at home and have babies. That’s why he picks on feminism.
The whole thing is nonsensical because not only does he not provide a shred of evidence to support his absurd statement, but if he were to try, he wouldn’t be able to find any because the causes for the lack of social mobility for working men (and women) has nothing to do with feminism and everything to to with class, capitalism and upper class clots like him.
I agree completely Alison – the underlying agenda to his words is that the man, in his mind (and sadly lots of other men’s minds) is always the breadwinner and women have supplanted the breadwinner. He obviously hasn’t cottoned to the fact that women can now be breadwinners too, and indeed are, up and down the country, especially in single parent families where the male breadwinner has left for pastures new.
Obviously his view is based upon an old fashioned model of woman at home with children, man at work supporting woman at home with children. However, he is married to the artist Sarah Butterfield who has consistently produced works of art for the past 20 years, so not too sure whose marriage he is thinking of. I wonder what Ms Butterfield thinks of his comments? Does he even talk to any women? To think he, and men like him, are running our country. How is this possible?