subscribe: Posts | Comments

Indiana woman incarcerated for killing baby in suicide bid

3 comments

Prison barsSummary of story from The Daily Beast, April 13, 2011

A pregnant woman in Indiana who tried to kill herself with rat poison was thrown into prison by the state after the baby that she was carrying died.

Bei Bei Shuai, 34, tried to commit suicide last Christmas using rat poison, but was saved by friends.

Bei Bei Shuai, a Chinese restaurant owner, was 33 weeks pregnant. She survived the suicide attempt, but her foetus ultimately did not.

A girl was born via caesarean section, but was taken off life suport two days later.

The state of Indiana has responded by incarcerating the 34 year-old on charges of murder and attempted foeticide rather than with providing mental health support.

Today a judge will determine if Bei Bei will be released on bail.

The American Civil Liberties Union argues the charges are unconstitutional.

The group’s amicus brief stated: “If a woman can be criminally prosecuted for those acts or omissions (or medical conditions) that pose a threat to her health while pregnant, then the state’s control over her life would be limitless.”

The National Advocates for Pregnant Women, which is assisting with Ms Shaui’s defense, has been tracking hundreds of similar cases.

Women have been locked up on murder or attempted murder charges because they miscarry or because their baby dies soon after birth, and many other cases are based on statutes that effectively give fetuses more rights than the women upon whom they are physiologically dependent.

“States pass foeticide or similar laws in the wake of some horrible violence against a pregnant woman,” explained Lynn Paltrow, who founded and directs the National Advocates for Pregnant Women.

“They claim to protect pregnant women, but prosecutors turn around and use these laws against women themselves”. This can be often for taking illegal drugs, or, as happened last year in Iowa, for falling down stairs.

“What doesn’t make sense is that if the goal is to protect fetuses, such prosecutions only cause them more harm.

Women with addiction problems or mental health issues will avoid medical treatment for fear of criminal penalty -they may even seek an abortion – or they’ll be exposed to the notorious prison health system, Ms Paltrow points out.

WVoN comment: It seems to be a grave miscarriage of justice, a double blow, to incarcerate a woman who happened to be pregnant when she tried to kill herself. Instead she should be supported both emotionally and medically.

  1. While incarcerated, she can be treated for mental health. Killing your fetus is a crime and should be treated as such.

    • Jane Osmond says:

      Hmm, I think the real crime is that too many women find bringing a baby into the world almost impossible due to the lack of money and support they face. Perhaps if this was addressed no woman would need to make such an awful choice.

    • I think her aim was primarily to kill herself and not her foetus and was therefore likely to not be in a culpable state.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *