subscribe: Posts | Comments

Naomi Wolf condemns Yale for allowing sex attacks on female students

5 comments

Summary of story from The Vancouver Sun, April 9, 2011

As the Ivy League alma mater of five US presidents, 18 Nobel laureates and countless captains of industry, Yale has one of the loftiest names in education.

But the university has found its reputation being dragged through the mud by a sex scandal that threatens to leave a stain on 300 years of academic excellence.

The US government has begun an investigation into a complaint by 16 female students at the Connecticut campus about unpunished sexual assaults and threatening rampages by gangs of young men (see WVoN story).

They claim Yale’s management has allowed the cultivation of a “sexually hostile environment”, in which misogyny flourishes and sexual attacks on young women are frequent.

Details of the most serious charges – concerning sexual assaults on several girls – have not been made public to protect the victims’ identities.

However, a 26-page dossier discloses a series of incidents. Several involve college fraternities – social societies that often have drunken initiation rites.

One night last October, a group of young men attempting to join the Delta Kappa Epsilon (DKE) fraternity gathered outside the dormitories of new female students and chanted: “No means yes!”

The “band of loud men shouting threatening and pornographic language” terrified teenagers who had just arrived for their first year, complainants, led by Hannah Zeavin, 20, claim.

Another incident saw a group of young men from Zeta Psi surround the entrance to a women’s building at midnight, holding a sign stating: “We Love Yale Sluts.”

In 2009 an email titled “pre season scouting report” rated 50 freshman women by the number of drinks male students would need before taking them to bed.

Naomi Wolf, the feminist author and Yale alumna, claimed the university had been “systematically covering up” sexual assaults for years, which it denied.

Dave Hunter, the executive director of Zeta Psi (a social college fraternity at approximately 50 schools in the United States),said that the students’ complaint had been filed by a group “with a political agenda”.

“They are pushing for women’s rights and using any kind of incident,” he said.

Referring to the assaults, he added: “You’re saying all these things happened – why were they not reported at the time?”

Alexandra Brodsky, 21, a Yale student, described Mr Hunter’s comments as “absurd”.

“Six or seven of my friends have been raped,” she said. “Attitudes like this show why it’s been left to a group of undergraduates to take action over such outrageous, indefensible behaviour.”

In a statement, Yale said it did not believe it had broken the law but would “co-operate fully with the investigation”.

“Our resolve that sexual misconduct is not to be tolerated remains as strong as any institution’s. We will continue to act on any episode of sexual misconduct as vigorously and effectively as we can,” the statement said.

WVoN comment: “Dave Hunter, the executive director of Zeta Psi, said that the students’ complaint had been filed by a group “with a political agenda”. “They are pushing for women’s rights and using any kind of incident.”

‘They?’  ‘Any kind of incident?’

So the very real misogyny that has been displayed by the incidents outlined above are not worth considering then?  Let’s hope the complaint succeeds in educating young men as to what is appropriate behaviour towards women.

  1. Jackie says:

    It is my belief that the personal is political and that protesting against an environment of violent misogyny is a laudable political act. Dave Hunter’s dismissal of the complaints of women students is part and parcel of the backlash against feminism – i.e. hostility towards women standing up for their rights. Instead of trying to undermine women why is Yale not taking the allegations of rape seriously and also sorting out the vile misogynist culture that appears to dominate on this campus?

    • Jane Osmond says:

      Yes indeed Jackie. The women who are protesting are to be congratulated. Compare this to the story earlier about the Davis campus (Uni of California) and their feminist film festival. The gap is enormous.

  2. I want to take issue with some of the newspaper reporting here, because it’s not just Dave Hunter who is complicit in covering up what seems to be a violent misogynistic culture at Yale. The Vancouver Sun article states that:

    “One night last October, a group of young men attempting to join the Delta Kappa Epsilon (DKE) fraternity gathered outside the dormitories of new female students and chanted: “No means yes!”

    The “band of loud men shouting threatening and pornographic language” terrified teenagers who had just arrived for their first year, complainants, led by Hannah Zeavin, 20, claim.”

    My parents get the Daily Telegraph and I compulsively torture myself by reading it when I’m at home, and they reported this chant and the criticism in the same way.

    American feminist websites like Jezebel that have been covering this story since it broke report that the chant was in fact ‘No means yes! Yes means anal!’ Missing out this second sentence makes it look like the complainants are overreacting when they criticise the ‘pornographic language’ used by some Yale men, since ‘No means yes!’, although incredibly objectionable, is not by itself pornographic.

    I assume that the Telegraph and the Vancouver Sun missed out the second sentence because the word ‘anal’ might offend their readers’ delicate sensibilities (speculating on the reasons for this is interesting). But isn’t that the point of this story? The mens’ language was pornographic and intended to offend and threaten – if newspapers misrepresent the court case in this way they present the complainants as a bunch of hysterical women, reinforcing stereotypes about the people who report sexual harrassment and assault, even though I’m sure that most people would find the abuses at Yale shocking.

  3. Jane Osmond says:

    Good point Hannah – when I first came across this story I was horrified to think that young women who were attending a university for the first time (possibly the first time they have been away from home in some cases) were being subjected to this kind of threatening language. Terrifying. That is why it is so brilliant that they are fighting back.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *