New gender bill for toilet users in Maine slammed
Summary of story from Kennebec Journal, April 13, 2011
Proposed legislation in Maine aims to sort toilet users according to ‘biological sex’, but opponents say it would infringe the rights of some Maine citizens and invades their privacy.
Currently users are able to choose which bathroom, male or female, they use, based on the gender with which they identify.
State Representative Ken Fredette is behind the new bill, ‘L.D. 1046′.
Fredette’s measure has been designed to eliminate the ability of transgender people to sue based on discrimination if they are denied use of their preferred restrooms.
In testimony before the Legislature’s Judiciary Committee Fredette said: “(This bill) permits schools, colleges and private businesses to establish bathrooms based on biological sex and to not be sued in Superior Court for simply doing that.”
A case decided last year involved a middle school boy in Orono who identifies himself as a girl and was not allowed to use the girls’ bathroom.
In the other case, decided in 2009, a transgender woman was denied use of the women’s restroom at Denny’s Restaurant in Auburn.
Both instances prompted lawsuits, though the Denny’s case was resolved out of court.
But those opposing Fredette’s proposal say it is an erosion of civil rights.
“This is a repeal bill,” said Jennifer Levi, director of Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders’ Transgender Rights Project.
“The reality is that the current law is working and it’s working fine. In nearly six years of nondiscrimination law being enforced, only three cases have ever been filed involving transgender people being denied access to restrooms.”
Other groups opposing the bill include the Maine Civil Liberties Union, the Center for Prevention of Hate Violence, the Maine Women’s Lobby, Maine’s Transgender Network, the Maine branch of the National Association of Social Workers and the Religious Coalition Against Discrimination.
The Maine Restaurant Association testified but did not take a position on the bill.
The Judiciary Committee will schedule a vote on the issue in the coming weeks.
















A bit conflicted on this. If the toilets are single stalls (i.e. not part of another room) then obviously no problem. But if the toilets are part of another room, then I am not sure how comfortable I would be with a man in a woman’s space, not least because this is open to abuse by abusers.