subscribe: Posts | Comments

Release figures on late abortions, orders High Court

0 comments

Summary of a story from the Daily Mail, cialis April 21, 2011

Figures on late abortions must be released to the public, the High Court in Britain has ruled.

The Information Tribunal ruled 18 months ago that the number of women having late abortions over minor abnormalities should be released.

This resulted in a legal challenge by the Department of Health (DoH) which claimed the move could lead to the identification of women who had undergone late abortions. The DoH says there are fewer than ten such abortions a year.

Abortion on ‘social’ grounds is only legal in Britain in the first 24 weeks of pregnancy, but the 1967 Abortion Act makes it legal up to birth if there is a substantial risk of ‘serious’ physical or mental abnormality.

Lawyers for the DoH had argued the decision by the Information Tribunal was legally flawed.

James Eadie QC, for the DoH, said patients could be identified if the data was put together with other public information, with ‘awful’ consequences for patients.

But Mr Justice Cranston said there had been no error of law and the tribunal was right to conclude the risk of identification was ‘extremely remote’.

It was also entitled to conclude that release of the material to a body like ProLife was ‘proportionate’ and necessary to inform the controversial public debate on abortion.

The judge put a stay on any of the data being released to give the DoH time to appeal.

Official figures suggest more than 120 women a year are having abortions after the upper time limit, with 29 at 32 weeks and over.

However, there are no figures available showing what criteria were used to approve termination and how many were for minor abnormalities.

Outside the High Court, Josephine Quintavalle of the ProLife Alliance said: ‘This is a great victory for freedom of information and accountability and most importantly for the rights of the disabled unborn child.’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *